Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images
Some stuff to like from unheralded prospects while the Twins’ top prospects struggled to stay on the field.
With the Twins off to a disappointing start, I’ve found myself paying closer attention to what’s happening in the lower ranks. Let’s get into what’s stood out from the first month of Minor League Baseball throughout Minnesota’s farm system.
Note: All stats are through May 1, 2025.
Carson McCusker: Knocking on the Door?
Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images
The mammoth-sized corner outfielder has been turning heads, and not just for his 6’8”, 250-pound frame. Originally a 26th-round pick in 2017 by the
Brewers, the Twins signed McCusker (and hilarious tiny shortstop Payton Eeles) out of Indy ball last summer. Since joining the Twins, he’s simply raked.
McCusker had a respectable, if underwhelming, .841 OPS with 98 games in AA and 24 in AAA. This season, he has been tearing the cover off the ball with a .325/.398/.651 (1.049 OPS) batting line, crushing seven homers in 27 games. The problem for McCusker, and any player of his size, is strikeouts.
There are rare exceptions like Aaron Judge and James Wood, but it’s hard for players this physically large to be effective MLB hitters. The levers are so long that swings tend to be slower and easier for established Big Leaguers to exploit. Matt Wallner, a fellow large-limbed corner outfielder, offsets his high strikeout rate with one of the best walk and chase rates in the league. McCusker, on the other hand, has an unsightly 31% strikeout rate to an 8.5% walk rate. For context, Wallner’s walk rate was typically in the 12-15% range throughout the minors, depending on the season.
At nearly 27 years old, McCusker won’t appear on any top prospects list, but with Wallner out for most of May with a hamstring injury, the Twins have to seriously consider adding him to the MLB roster. It can’t be worse than giving the likes of Mickey Gasper, Kody Clemens, and Jonah Bride regular at-bats.
Twins Top 100 Updates
Photo by Joe Robbins/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
The Twins have four players on various national Top 100 lists, though unfortunately all are currently injured. Let’s take a look where things stand.
Walker Jenkins, OF
A consensus top-ten prospect, Jenkins has once again been hampered by injury to start the year. After missing the first two months with a hamstring injury in 2024, Jenkins has managed to appear in just two AA games so far this season. The Twins announced earlier this week that Jenkins will miss most of May recovering from a sprained ankle that required a cortisone injection this week. Jenkins’ performance has been elite when on the field, but injuries are the reason he fell to the Twins when they selected him fifth overall in the 2023
MLB Draft.
Emmanuel Rodriguez, OF
The Twins’ other top hitting outfielder has played in more games but hasn’t been particularly effective. After missing most of 2024 with a sprained thumb that required offseason surgery, Rodriguez has been hampered by his
other thumb early on this year. He injured it on a swing early this season, limiting his effectiveness in the 17 games he’s played this season. He has just a .231/.359/.277 batting line with an unsightly 35% strikeout rate accompanied by his elite 17% walk rate. It’s a small sample size from a clearly injured player, so I wouldn’t take too much away from these results so far.
Luke Keaschall, IF/OF
You know him, you love him, and as a Minnesota Twin that means that he was hurt before he could play 10 games. Keaschall reached base in all seven games he played for the Twins and tied an MLB record by stealing five bases in his first five games. Unfortunately, that run ended when he got hit on the right forearm with a fastball, resulting in a fracture. Luckily, it was a non-displaced fracture so the Twins are expecting him back sometime this summer.
Charlee Soto, RHP
Soto is more of a fringe-top 100 player, but he’s been starting to sprinkle some appearances at the bottom of prospect lists. Soto was the Twins’ second first-rounder in 2023, after Jenkins, a flame-throwing prep arm out of Florida. Soto’s fastball/slider combo are the name of the game, but he ended up on the injured list after making just three starts this season. In his limited sample, Soto maintained his high strikeout rate while nearly cutting his walk rate in half, a good sign for him moving forward. He’ll miss extended time with a tricep strain, one of the arm injuries that can be a warning sign for eventual Tommy John surgery.
Post-Top Prospect Check-In
Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images
David Festa and Zebby Matthews aren’t considered prospects anymore after their second-half contributions in 2024, but both remain critical pieces to the Twins’ future. Either as important contributors themselves or trade capital.
David Festa, RHP
Festa made three effective starts for the Twins in Pablo Lopez’s absence, and he’ll likely be their next call whenever Minnesota needs another starter. Festa has gotten hit around a bit in AAA starts compared to his MLB ones (4.40 AAA ERA vs 1.38 MLB ERA), but it’s worth noting that players like Festa typically use their AAA to tinker with their arsenal and work on what they need to improve against Big League hitters. Festa’s walk rate is way down at AAA compared to MLB, so he’s likely working on how his pitches play within the strike zone.
Zebby Matthews, RHP
Zebulon was the talk of Twins Spring Training, emerging with new, elite velocity on both his fastball and cutter, allowing his other secondaries to play up as well. In five starts in St. Paul, Matthews has a 1.93 ERA/2.31 RA9 while allowing just 18 hits in 23.1 innings and racking up 11.2 strikeouts per nine innings. His stuff and strikeouts are up, as is his normally pristine walk rate, though that may be intentional with Zebby working to induce more chase from MLB-caliber hitters rather than just overpowering hitters in the zone, which he can get by on against lesser competition.
Prospects on the Rise
Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images
They’re not top prospects yet, but they could be soon if they keep up their strong starts.
Dasan Hill, LHP (A)
Hill was the Twins’ second-round selection in last year’s draft. A lanky left-handed prep arm, Minnesota went well above slot value to get him in their system last summer, which has already paid dividends. Hill’s stuff is way up from last season, averaging 96 MPH on his primary sinker, leading to an insane 21 strikeouts in 10.2 innings in 2025. Still only 19, the Twins will be conservative with his workload, but he has the stuff to rise through the ranks quickly.
Connor Prielipp, LHP (AA)
The only question for Prielipp is if he can stay healthy. Long viewed as a potential top-five draft pick, Prielipp’s college Tommy John surgery let the Twins select him in the second round of the 2022 draft. He missed most of 2023 and 2024 with a second TJS, but is healthy this season and overpowering AA hitters with a 17:2 K/BB rate in 10.2 innings. He’ll have an outside chance at a bullpen role with the Twins late this season, should they need him.
Danny De Andrade, SS (A+)
De Andrade has been a favorite among prospect evaluators for a few years because of his slick fielding, but he has struggled mightily at the plate. This season, he has a .884 OPS as he’s started to finally tap into some of his power. He’ll still need to bring up his walk rate and limit strikeouts, but the glove alone gives De Andrade a high floor.
Other Prospects to Watch
Photo by Ed Bailey/Minor League Baseball via Getty Images
Literally Any Catchers
With Christian Vazquez a free agent after this season and Ryan Jeffers the following season, the Twins desperately need a catcher to emerge from their farm system. Here are a couple names to watch.
- Ricardo Oliver (AA): Olivar may be their best bet who is relatively close to the Big Leagues. Olivar has a .861 OPS in 18 AA games, but he’s split his time evenly between catcher, left field, and designated hitter. The biggest question will be his ability to stick defensively behind the plate.
- Patrick Winkel (AAA): Winkel is already 26 and struggled last season in his first taste of AAA action, but he’s off to a strong start in 2025. Albeit in only six games, the big lefty has a .985 OPS in the young season.
- Nate Baez (A+): Baez is the furthest away, but at 24 years old, he could rise through the Twins’ system quickly if he keeps hitting. He has a 1.002 OPS in 18 games this season with a 17% walk rate and more walks than strikeouts, but like all catching prospects, the biggest question is if his glove can stick behind the plate.
The Next Line of Starting Pitchers
- Travis Adams, RHP (AAA): Adams has a 2.55 ERA and 24:3 K:BB ratio through 24.3 innings. Already on the 40-man roster, he’ll be the next man up after Festa and Zebby.
- Andrew Morris, RHP (AAA): Morris has been playing with fire all season, allowing 29 hits and 8 walks in 21.2 innings. He’s done a good job limiting the damage with his 4.57 ERA, but he’ll need to find a way to limit the hits before he makes it to the Bigs.
- Marco Raya, RHP (AAA): Raya may have the highest ceiling of this entire group, but he’s had arguably the toughest go of anyone here as well. With 21 hits allowed and 12 walks in just 12 innings, his first taste of AAA action is off to a rocky start.
- Cory Lewis, RHP (AAA): You may have heard of Lewis and his surprising high-velocity knuckleball that he’s mixed into his offerings. It hasn’t baffled hitters at AAA like it has at lower levels, but knuckleballers are notoriously fickle. He has a 9.00 ERA with six homers allowed in 15 innings.
Recent Top Draft Picks/International Players
Let’s speedrun a few final names.
- Kaelen Culpepper, IF (A+): .333/.400/.508, 2 HR, 4 SB in 16 games
- Kyle DeBarge, IF (A+): .279/.402/.481, 4 HR, 14 SB in 26 games
- Billy Amick, IF/OF (A+): .342/.475/.447, 0 HR, 15% BB rate in 21 games
- Gabriel Gonzalez, OF (A+): .302/.368/.448, 2 HR in 24 games
- Aaron Sabato, 1B (AA): .296/.415/.523, 2 HR, 15% BB rate in 14 games