Washington Nationals
Team Leader
The Clutchest Washington Nationals of 2025 May Not Be Who You Expect
Source: https://www.federalbaseball.com/general/86919/the-clutchest-nationals-2025-may-not-be-who-expect
![]()
Everyone knows how bad Nathaniel Lowe’s tenure with the Nationals went, from posting career low marks in nearly every category to being released from the club in August. What many don’t know is that when it mattered the most, Nathaniel Lowe showed up more than almost anyone in 2025, tying with James Wood atop the “Clutch” leaderboards according to Fangraphs, a stat that measures a player’s performance in high leverage situations as compared to their performance in all other times.
In 54 high-leverage at-bats in 2025 (maybe a few with the Red Sox, but mostly with the Nats), Nathaniel Lowe hit .278 and posted a 135 wRC+, numbers much more in line with what Nationals fans expected out of him. Many of those big hits came early on in the season, such as his bases-clearing double in Miami or his go-ahead 3-run shot against the Phillies, both in April. Lowe’s problems arose in all other situations, as in low and medium-leverage at-bats, Lowe posted a 91 and 81 wRC+, respectively.
The difference is even more drastic when comparing his performance with runners on base versus with no one on, as with runners on base, he posted a 131 wRC+ in 245 at-bats, but with no one on, he posted a 56 wRC+ in 295 at-bats. Perhaps there is some explanation, such as Lowe being more locked in when the lights got bright, but the most likely solution is that’s just baseball.
Tied atop the “Clutch” leaderboards with Lowe is James Wood, who also happened to be the Nats’ best hitter period in 2025. While Wood’s numbers were respectable in low-leverage situations, posting a 108 wRC+ in 335 at-bats, he truly turned it on in the clutch, as he posted a 148 wRC+ in medium-leverage at-bats and an astonishing 162 wRC+ in high-leverage at-bats. The difference in Wood’s numbers between low and high leverage at-bats is vast, as he walked 12% more (perhaps due to teams pitching around him), struck out 9% less, and raised his OBP and SLG by over .100 points in high-leverage at-bats as compared to low-leverage ones.
On the other side of the spectrum, the least clutch Nationals offensively was Josh Bell, who performed great in low-leverage at-bats, posting a 121 wRC+, but struggled in all others, posting a 94 wRC+ in medium-leverage and 77 wRC+ in low-leverage at-bats. He slugged close to the same in higher leverage situations, with his slugging percentage dropping, but not drastically, but he struggled to get on base the same, posting a .261 on-base percentage in the clutch, well down from a .334 OBP and .325 OBP in low and medium-leverage at-bats, respectively.
On the pitching side of things, the clutchest National was one Nats fans may not have anticipated, as Jackson Rutledge edges out Cole Henry as the king of clutch for the 2025 Nationals pitching staff. Rutledge got rocked in low and medium-leverage situations in 2025, posting a 5.54 and 5.94 FIP in each, but when the going got tough, Rutledge got going, as in high-leverage situations, he posted a 3.56 FIP and allowed 0 home runs. His walk rate went up and his strikeout rate went down in high-leverage situations, so I wouldn’t expect this clutch factor to carry over to 2026, but it’s interesting to see how a reliever who seemingly struggled most of the year was able to turn it on when the club needed him to.
Source: https://www.federalbaseball.com/general/86919/the-clutchest-nationals-2025-may-not-be-who-expect