Photo by John Byrum/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Taking a look at a Jets free agent signing
The
New York Jets signed former
Cincinnati Bengals defensive tackle Jay Tufele to a one-year contract early on in free agency. Today we break Tufele down in detail.
The 25-year old Tufele is listed at 6’3” and 310 pounds and was a fourth round pick out of USC in 2021. He has started five games in his NFL career, recording 44 tackles, three tackles for loss, four quarterback hits, a pass defensed and half a sack in four years.
Background
Tufele was almost 300 pounds as a high schooler and was a five-star recruit who enrolled at USC in 2017 and redshirted his first season.
In 2018, he saw action in a rotational role that saw him start five games. He ended the season with 23 tackles, 4.5 tackles for loss and 3.5 sacks, earning all-Pac 12 second team honors. He also returned a fumble for a 48-yard touchdown.
As a redshirt sophomore in 2019, he was a first team all-Pac 12 selection after racking up 41 tackles, 6.5 tackles for loss and 4.5 sacks.
However, he opted out of the 2020 season due to the Covid-19 pandemic, deciding to instead prepare to be an early entry into the 2021 draft. While some sites had him listed as a probable day two and possible late first round pick ahead of the 2020 season, sitting out a year hurt his stock and he was selected by the
Jacksonville Jaguars in the fourth round.
Tufele struggled to make an impact as a rookie, ending up with just two tackles in four games. He was released in final cuts ahead of the 2022 season. However, the Bengals claimed him off waivers and he found himself a home as a rotational lineman with them over the past three seasons.
In 2022, he played in seven games, starting two. He ended up with 16 tackles, two tackles for loss and two quarterback hits. He then had 11 tackles in 10 games as a reserve in 2023.
Last season, he played in 13 games, starting three, and ended up with 15 tackles and the first half-sack of his career. However, the Bengals did not extend him, so he hit the open market at the end of the year.
The Jets signed Tufele to a one-year minimum salary deal during the early stages of free agency.
Let’s move on to some more in-depth analysis of what Tufele brings to the table as a player, based on extensive research and film study.
Measurables/Athleticism
Tufele was already an NFL-sized defensive tackle by the time he was about 16 but he lacks ideal length. Having been part of the draft class that didn’t get a chance to work out at the combine due to the pandemic, he impressed during his pro day workout with a 5.02 time in the 40-yard dash and 30 bench press reps.
His explosiveness and agility numbers were slight below average for the position but he shows flashes of both in his film.
Usage
Tufele has played the majority of his reps at the NFL and college levels as a traditional B-gap defensive tackle, mostly in four-man fronts. He has lined up outside or over the center from time to time but not very often.
He has never had a chance to be a ball carrier, other than on his fumble return in college, but he actually has some experience at this, as he also has a background in rugby.
Motor
Tufele brings plenty of energy as he battles in the trenches. He keeps working after his first move is repelled and hustles in pursuit.
He hasn’t really had a starter’s workload at any stage of his career, with the most snaps he’s played in an NFL game being just 37. However, he has played 50 or more a couple of times in preseason.
Pass rush
With eight sacks in two seasons at USC, the Jaguars and Bengals probably expected more production from Tufele as a pass rusher. However, he has just half a sack in regular season action and doesn’t have one in preseason either.
Despite this, he has shown promise at times. A feature of his rushing is his violent hand work, as he chops down to keep offensive linemen’s hands off him.
He brings power but also has some quickness and agility and can even get to the quarterback versus a double team.
However, his overall pressure rates have been underwhelming, both in regular season and preseason action.
Run defense
Tufele’s run defense grades on analysis sites such as Pro Football Focus have typically been below average. He is often controlled at the point of attack or sealed off as his momentum is used against him to take him out of a play.
He has made plenty of impressive plays at the NFL level though. He displays the quickness to shoot gaps and explode into the backfield.
Perhaps his most impressive attribute is his strength. When he gets his pads low, he can hold his ground against a double team and even leverage his way into running lanes.
He’s efficient on the move too, reacting and hustling downhill with good range to prevent this run from getting to the second level.
Technique
As noted, Tufele has good strength and uses his hands well. When he combines this with good technique he can be effective at leveraging his way off blocks to maintain his gap.
As a pass rusher, he isn’t regarded as someone who will string moves together, but his athletic ability means he can look good when he tries to win matchups this way, so this could be an area with growth potential.
Special teams
Other than one snap rushing a punt, Tufele’s only role on special teams in college and at the pro level has been on the kick block unit.
He had one penalty in college but also had this crucial field goal block to preserve a big win against a Pac 12 rival.
Tackling
Tufele hasn’t been a very productive tackler at the NFL level as he’s averaged less than 1.5 tackles per game despite being more productive in college. However, he does contribute by bottling up runs for other players to clean up while he occupies blockers.
Missed tackles have never been a major issue for him, although he had three last season after having only had two in his first three years combined.
Coverage
Tufele never dropped into coverage in college and has only done so once at the NFL level on a play where the Bengals gave up a touchdown although this wasn’t his fault.
He batted down one pass at the line in college and has done this once in the NFL too. He will also hustle to get in on the play on short passes.
Instincts/Intelligence
The book on Tufele as he entered the NFL was that he was more of an attacking lineman who was less comfortable when tasked with a read and react assignment. However, there are signs that this is something he’s improved at since being drafted.
His awareness can sometimes be lacking when he is hit with a down block and he has yet to develop a good feel for transitioning to counter moves when initially repelled by pass protectors.
Attitude/Demeanor
Tufele’s coaches and teammates have been complimentary about his attitude and character. He’s viewed as a competitor with mental and physical toughness.
His on-field discipline at the NFL level has been excellent with just one defensive penalty in his career, for defensive holding. He had four in college.
He’s not a vocal leader and can be emotional at times, but he’s worked on his maturity and is regarded as a hard worker who is coachable.
As a measure of his determination, when he was in high school, he was once chewed out by the coaches for being two minutes late to an early morning meeting and when they asked him why he was late it turned out he had walked 15 miles to be there.
Injuries
At the NFL level, Tufele has missed 33 games, although most of these have been as a healthy scratch. He did miss six games on injured reserve in his rookie year, though, having broken his hand in a pre-game warmup.
He had some issues in college and high school too. He didn’t play as a high school senior due to a torn ligament in his foot and dealt with a hand injury that required stitches and bothered him throughout the 2019 season at USC. He didn’t miss any game or practice time due to that, though, showcasing his toughness.
Scheme Fit
The Jets signed a trio of veteran linemen to low-level deals in free agency and Tufele will compete for a role with the other two (Byron Cowart and Derrick Nnadi). You can expect any of these to end up in a rotational role as a 4-3 defensive tackle, which would be similar to the role Tufele has already played in his NFL career.
Tufele was a former teammate of current Jet Alijah Vera-Tucker at USC and played with Andre Cisco and Quincy Williams at Jacksonville. He was also a teammate of punter Austin McNamara in Cincinnati.
Conclusions
As a five-star prospect who was drafted in the mid rounds and was a rotational contributor so far in his career, it’s perhaps surprising that Tufele already hit the open market and wasn’t able to get anything more than a minimum salary deal. Especially when some of his film is actually pretty impressive.
He’s still only 25 and it’s a young 25 because he didn’t play in 2016 (injury), 2017 (redshirt) or 2020 (opt-out) so there is plenty of tread on those tires and, the Jets will hope, some residual untapped potential.
It can be treated as a prove-it deal for Tufele, who will no doubt work hard and with a chip on his shoulder as he seeks to establish himself. It should be a good competition on the defensive interior this summer.