New York Jets
Role Player
Scouting Jets UDFA punter Kai Kroeger
Source: https://www.ganggreennation.com/2025/5/20/24432964/scouting-new-york-jets-udfa-punter-kai-kroeger
![]()
Photo by John Byrum/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Taking a look at a Jets punter
The New York Jets recently signed former South Carolina punter Kai Kroeger as an undrafted free agent. Let’s therefore look at Kroeger in more detail.
The 22-year old Kroeger is listed at 6’3” and 212 pounds. He was undrafted out of South Carolina in April. The Jets signed Kroeger, a two-time all-SEC first teamer, after he attended their rookie minicamp on a tryout basis.
Background
Kroeger was a two-star recruit out of high school, where he had also played as a wide receiver and three years as a quarterback.
He became South Carolina’s punter at the start of his freshman year in 2020 and would go on to hold the job for five years, playing in a team-record-tying 61 games in his career.
After posting underwhelming numbers in his first two seasons, with a gross average of 43 yards per punt and a net below 40, Kroeger broke out in 2022 and earned all-SEC first team and all-American honors with a gross average of 46 and a net of 42.
This included a sensational performance against the Clemson Tigers where he posted a high average and landed a handful of punts close to the goal line, including two late in the game as the Gamecocks held on for the upset win.
Head coach Shane Beamer said that Kroeger was the best punter in the nation that year and he couldn’t believe he wasn’t a finalist for a Ray Guy award.
2023 saw a slight regression towards the same kind of numbers Kroeger had in his first two years, but his 2024 season was even better than his 2022 season. His gross average was just under 48 and his net was just under 44, both career highs. He was fourth and sixth in the nation in those two categories.
Kroeger was again voted first-team all-SEC but snubbed from being a Ray Guy award finalist. However, he headed into the draft with plenty of interest as he visited with all 32 teams. While he didn’t earn an undrafted free agent contract, seven different teams invited him to their rookie camp and Kroeger eventually signed for the Jets after attending theirs earlier this month.
Measurables/Athleticism
Kroeger is a similar size to Austin McNamara, his current competition for the Jets’ punting role after the release of Thomas Morstead last week.
He didn’t do any of the workouts at his pro day, but he shows flashes of his athletic ability from having been a position player in high school in some of his film. For example, he showed off adequate wheels on this two-point conversion.
![]()
Leg Strength
Kroeger showed good leg strength over the course of his career, with 68 punts of 50 yards or more, including four of 70 or more.
![]()
As noted, his gross punting average was fourth best in the nation in 2024 as he posted a career high, although it’s worth noting that 12 NFL punters surpassed that number last year.
Hang time is a concern because his numbers per PFF are consistently low. However, these numbers are notoriously difficult to record accurately and, in any case, can be misleading if a punter will often deliberately hit line drives away from the return man to limit return yardage.
At the Shrine Bowl, as if to prove himself capable of high-hang time punting as required for the pro game, Kroeger averaged an excellent 4.4 seconds of hang time per punt with one pinned near the goal line.
Directional Punting
Kroeger’s numbers for directional punting are solid as he has put over 40 percent of his career punts inside the 20, including over 50 percent in 2022.
This includes plenty of highlights of punts being downed at the goal line, including that game mentioned above against Clemson which turned him into a folk hero.
![]()
His touchback rate has been good throughout his career, although it’s worth noting that he had a career-high six in 2024 and posted his worst touchback percentage of his career at 13 percent. It was just six percent in his first four seasons.
In terms of limiting returns, this is something Kroeger definitely got better at over the course of his career. He gave up 285 yards on 23 returns in his first two seasons but only 201 on 49 returns in the three years since then, reducing the average from 12.4 to 4.1 yards per return.
The most return yards he gave up in a game over his final three seasons was 36, on three returns.
Kicking
While Kroeger doesn’t have any experience as a placekicker, which could cause the team to look in another direction in an emergency, he did kick off four times in 2024.
One of these was a successful onside kick which gave them a late chance for a potential upset win. It was a unique kick too, drop-kicked with plenty of spin on the ball.
![]()
Tackling
Kroeger only had one special teams tackle in his career, but it was an important one to save a touchdown. He had limited opportunities to make any tackles over the past three years without any long returns surrendered.
![]()
Holding
Kroeger has been regarded as a solid holder over the past five seasons. Having played wide receiver in high school he likely has better than average hands.
The most exciting aspect of his potential in a holder role is that he has channeled some of that high school quarterback experience into some decent success on fakes.
For his career, he was 7-for-10 for 205 yards and three touchdowns and that would have been 8-for-11 with four touchdowns if this incredible throw hadn’t have been wiped out by a lineman’s penalty.
![]()
Intangibles/Miscellaneous
It’s not just on fake field goals that Kroeger has had passing success. He’s also looked good on fake punts. On more than one occasion, he’s looked one way before throwing in the other direction to manipulate or read the defense and he’s shown good accuracy down the field.
![]()
Kroeger’s scouting report is critical of how quickly he gets his punts off, but that doesn’t seem to be a significant issue as he only had one punt blocked and that was due to a rusher being completely unblocked.
![]()
An alternative read on this could be that he is often able to take his time because teams don’t send much of a rush due to being worried about his potential to make a play with his arm. In addition, he showed on the fake field goal clip above that he potentially has the movement skills to avoid a rusher and still get a kick off.
Kroeger has good intangibles based on how decorated he was in college. He twice won the team’s special teams MVP award as well as the 2022 Nutrition award, was a co-winner of the President’s Outstanding Student-Athlete award, was nominated for the SEC’s prestigious H. Boyd McWhorter Award and was named five different times to the SEC academic honor roll.
He also showed good leadership and a willingness to improve. When the team hired Joe DeCamallis, a coach with plenty of NFL experience, he brought with him a series of new drills and made a minor tweak to Kroeger’s elbow position which obviously yielded positive results.
Finally, while he didn’t play in a cold climate, Kroger has had some good punting success in wet or windy conditions.
Conclusions
The fact that the Jets signed Kroeger after getting an extended look at him during their rookie camp is significant. Releasing Morstead at the same time could be even more notable and perhaps indicative of them being high on the rookie.
It’s perhaps surprising that Kroeger had to go via the tryout route to earn an NFL contract because he was one of the top-rated punters heading into the draft.
However, with McNamara - a player who also has no NFL experience - as his only current competition, Kroeger has a realistic chance to win Morstead’s old job and give the Jets a younger, cheaper option with good upside.
Source: https://www.ganggreennation.com/2025/5/20/24432964/scouting-new-york-jets-udfa-punter-kai-kroeger