The Manning/Luck dilemna

[Homerunsox2005]

The Indianapolis Colts have the first pick in the NFL draft and likely will draft QB Andrew Luck. Current Colts QB Peyton Manning is coming off injury, and will likely be starting next year.

Should the Colts trade/cut Manning to let Luck be the QB there for the future?

Should the Colts keep Manning and Luck, and just have Luck be backup until Manning retires, and hope by then he is custom to the Colts scheme he will be an instant star?

Should the Colts trade their number one pick and try to get more draft picks later in the draft?

What should the Colts do?

 

[Mdolszak]

That's a tough one.
I think they should have Luck as backup for a year, and then go from there.

 

[wingnut]

Take Luck and let him learn from the vet. Do the samething the Pack did with Rodgers and Favre.

 

[bonafide555]

take luck

 

[2091401]

Jan 3, 2012 20:32:23 GMT -5 wingnut said:Take Luck and let him learn from the vet. Do the samething the Pack did with Rodgers and Favre.
Yeah, this is what I'm expecting the Colts to do... it makes the most sense.