Pittsburgh Penguins
Role Player
Summer 2025 Tiers of Security for the Penguins
Source: https://www.pensburgh.com/2025/5/25/24436971/summer-2025-tiers-of-security-for-the-penguins
![]()
Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images
Lots of players could be in play this offseason
Memorial Day is the unofficial kickoff for summer and with summer comes the season of roster movement across the NHL. The league is focused on the playoffs at this point, but trades have happened this time of year in the past due to the quick turnaround coming up with the NHL draft (June 27-28) coming up just before free agency opens (July 1).
Here’s how the Penguins stand to enter the summer.
Tier 1: Safe as can be
Call this the Jeff Carter Memorial Area — all of these players are clear to come back to the Pens in 2025-26 if they want to do so, courtesy of clauses in their contracts. Not to mention that the team likely wouldn’t be thinking about roster movement for them in the first place.
Sidney Crosby - Crosby re-signed with the Penguins through 2027 because he wants to stay with the team that has been his team for 20 years. That’s the reality of the situation, as hard as that fact can be to accept for some out there.
Evgeni Malkin - Some speculation never ends, but the one constant all along has been Malkin saying that he has been planning to come back to the Penguins in 2025-26, the last season on his contract.
Kris Letang - Letang has a full no movement clause in his contract this year. Given his age (38), time remaining on his contract (three years) and recent heart surgery, it doesn’t look like he’s leaving the Pens in the near future.
Tier 1b: The $10 million question..
Stay tuned!
Erik Karlsson - Karlsson has a full no movement, so he could be up a notch if he wanted. But he doesn’t fit nicely in the “no doubter” area after getting called out by Dubas and going through two unsatisfying seasons it might be time to rehome him with a team that is in contention. There’s got to be a path for Karlsson to remain in Pittsburgh since he’s got a big salary and two more years to go on it
Tier 2: Young, valuable players
This group of players are either off limits or close, because the Pens know them well enough that they have more value playing for them in the future than they would compared to what a different team would give up in a trade
Ville Koivunen - After a great rookie season split between the AHL and NHL, the Pens have to be thrilled and excited to see more out of Koivunen next season.
Rutger McGroarty - McGroarty could well be the next Penguin captain one day with his leadership skills and personality. The Pens stayed patient in 2024-25 was a
Owen Pickering - Kyle Dubas traded Brayden Yager last summer, so never say never when it comes to flipping young players. But unless something materializes to help the team, it would seem a good bet that Pickering is kept to see how much he can grow into the crucial second pro season.
Tier 3a: Veteran core, but...
This tier is probably the key to the Pens’ off-season. These are valuable players but with the team in the midst of their rebuild/turnover, they also can’t be considered absolute locks to return to Pittsburgh next fall depending on how much the Pens steer into getting younger.
Bryan Rust - Rust’s full no movement clause expires on July 1 and he will have zero trade protection written into his contract at that point. He’s now 33 and coming off a career-best season of 30 goals and 65 points. The head may say it’s time to cash in and move on (especially with three more seasons to go on his contract) but even though Rust doesn’t have formal trade protection his all-around play, the heart might pull more towards his effectiveness and role as a key player making him one that will be hard to move on from.
Rickard Rakell - This situation is similar to the above with much of Rust’s writeup applying here. Rakell just turned 32 and just had a career-best season himself with 35 goals and 70 points. The price for another team to acquire him will be sky high, if it’s not met the Penguins look totally content to keep a great winger and take value from him on the ice helping the club in that regard for a while longer yet.
Tier 3b: Well these guys are also here
Veterans who aren’t a huge piece but find themselves just hangin’ around
Blake Lizotte - Lizotte was quietly effective as a fourth liner. He’s probably not a player that other teams are tripping over to add right now but also does no harm in coming back and doing his thing for a while longer.
Danton Heinen - At a $2.25 million salary, Heinen wouldn’t be off limits to move but coming off a meh season there’s no reason to expect much to change any time soon. He’s pretty much the definition of just being around, not going to hurt but not going to contribute a lot or make much of a target for another team to seek out.
Ryan Shea - The Pens like Shea in the new Chad Ruhwedel mold of a player who can be scratched as the extra defenseman for long periods and jump back into the lineup as needed.
Tommy Novak - An injury stopped Novak’s time with the Pens almost as soon as it started after just two games. The team sounded fairly excited to see what he can do but even though Novak is new to Pittsburgh, he doesn’t fit being a young player at 28 so this seems like as good of a tier as any for him at this point.
Tier 4: Who would want them?
Likely to be safe because it’s not like anyone outside the league is seeking them
Kevin Hayes - He carries a $3.57 million cap hit that is bigger than his on ice value. Hayes has a lot of intangibles but his effectiveness and role can be spotty. Other teams are going to have younger, cheaper and better options to go after.
Noel Acciari - Could there be a market for one of the slowest and least productive players in the league that also has a $2 million salary? Maybe deeper into next season. Acciari is a warrior on the ice and surely liked by more coaches than a critic would allow but does anyone want 82 games from him now?
Alex Nedeljkovic - Nedeljkovic is a platonic ideal replacement level goalie. He posts average-ish stats, can be a decent 1B/backup but also comes with a $2.5 million salary that won’t make him an appealing pickup for NHL teams.
Vladislav Kolyachonok - Didn’t get a ton of traction after being claimed on waivers. Though a different style of player, Kolyachonok could be this year’s John Ludvig as a 7/8 type of defenseman that tries to find staying power in the lineup and faces another trip to the waiver wire if he falls short, likely isn’t anyone another team is going to bother going out and acquiring via a trade.
Tier 5: Team would love to move on
And probably not for a huge return
Tristan Jarry - Perhaps Jarry could move into tier 3, but at this point who knows what the future holds for him. He got waived last season and still has three more years to go on a $5.375 million cap hit. Can the Pens ever trust him again? They might not have a choice if there’s no great trade options. But trying to find a swap with retention and/or taking back a bad contract makes sense for all parties to get a fresh start.
Ryan Graves - Season two in Pittsburgh was just as poor for Graves as the first. His cap hit at $4.5 million is onerous, the four seasons remaining on it are even worse.
Tier 6: Free Agent decisions
There’s about a month to go before free agency starts, none of these players have been re-signed just yet. Read into that at your own risk for how much or little of a priority they may be..
Philip Tomasino (RFA) - Tomasino scored some goals and added a little bit of pop, but his fit in the lineup is questionable with players like Koivunen and McGroarty stepping up. It makes sense to bring Tomasino back for another season but his foothold on a job can be questioned.
Conor Timmins (RFA) - Dubas is clearly very fond of Timmins, there’s not much question that the Pens will qualify the defender and sign him up for next season and see where it goes from there.
Connor Dewar (RFA) - Was Dewar just a throw-in by Toronto to clear cap space and a contract out? Pittsburgh has a surplus of fourth line players. Dewar’s younger than many of them and a perfectly fine fourth liner if the team wants to keep him.
Vasily Ponomarev (RFA) - Ponomarev is an interesting case because Dubas has frequently said they think he’s close, but he’s barely played NHL games and made minimal impacts when in the lineup. He’s young enough to want to hang on to for at least another year to see if it can click but the clock is starting to tick and nothing
P.O. Joseph (RFA) - Well, round two with the Pens was definitely something that happened. It doesn’t seem like there’s a lot of urgency to see much more.
Matt Nieto (UFA) - Unfortunately a pair of major knee injuries derailed Nieto’s time with the Pens. Now at 32 and looking longer in the tooth than that, this looks like the end of the road.
Matt Grzelcyk (UFA) - We’ll always have those 39 assists! Grzelcyk’s redemption season was uneven at best, the Pens could always look to bring him back to keep eating tough minutes but likely will seek more capable alternatives.
Source: https://www.pensburgh.com/2025/5/25/24436971/summer-2025-tiers-of-security-for-the-penguins