Hall of Fame Game

[Cam Cam]

This is just a random idea for a forum game I came up with. This is kind of like this or that, but you say in or out instead. So, you are predicting whether a player will be in the hall of fame or not.

Example:

Poster 1: In. Peyton Manning?
Poster 2: In. Eli Manning?
Poster 3: Out. Randy Moss?

---

Okay, I will start.

Wes Welker?

 

[2091401]

Out. Corey Dillon?

 

[AlexanderNevermind]

OUT. RB Edgerrin James, IND


Great thread.

 

[Cam Cam]

In. Jerome Bettis?

 

[AlexanderNevermind]

In. QB Tony Romo, DAL

 

[Cam Cam]

Out. Kerry Collins?

 

[AlexanderNevermind]

Out. PR/KR/WR Devon Hester, CHI

 

[Cam Cam]

Devin Hester certainly has his place in history, but he does not deserve to be in the hall of fame. Out.

Andre Johnson?

 

[AlexanderNevermind]

Out. WR Terrell Owens, SF

 

[2091401]

In. Chad Johnson?

 

[AlexanderNevermind]

Out: Close however, DB Champ Bailey WAS/DEN

 

[Cam Cam]

In. Ben Roethlisberger?

 

[Homerunsox2005]

In. Devin Hester?

 

[Cam Cam]

One of the best returners ever, but he needs more than that to be in the hall of fame. As of right now, I say out.

Gary Anderson?

 

[Moss44]

Was very good, but I can't see a kicker in the hall.

Antonio Brown?

 

[2091401]

Too early to tell, and he's my favorite Steeler, but I'm gonna go with out for now.

While we're doing young'ns, AJ Green?

 

[Cam Cam]

Three Pro Bowls in three seasons. Not bad. If Andy Dalton and A.J. Green stay together, I think he will probably end up being in the Hall of Fame. Obviously, there is no telling what could happen in the future though. Cincinatti could decide that Andy Dalton isn't their guy, dump him, and keep A.J. Green. Then A.J. Green could end up being like Larry Fitzgerald. An amazing receiver playing with horrible quarterbacks.

Bill Cowher?