Giants Dexter Lawrence No. 17 among NFL.com’s top 100 players

gettyimages-2179676110.jpg


Dexter Lawrence continues to ascend amongst the NFL’s best.

The New York Giants defensive lineman has come in at No. 17 in the NFL’s top 100. This is Lawrence’s third consecutive season in the top 100, coming in at 28th in 2023 and 24th in 2024. Lawrence now also has the distinct honor of being the highest ranking defender on the list for the Giants.

Lawrence has been a dominate force since being drafted by the Giants in 2019. The defensive lineman is coming off his third consecutive Pro Bowl season and has earned second team All-Pro honors twice in his career. Philadelphia Eagles tackle Lane Johnson perfectly sums up what it is like to be lined up on the other side.

“I lined against him one time. He lined up at linebacker,” Johnson said. “It felt like I had a S.W.A.T. team door hit me in the chest. He kind of does what he wants when he wants.”

Despite only playing 12 games in 2024, Lawrence was still able to finish the season with nine sacks and eight tackles for loss. Getting into the backfield is a habit for the defensive lineman so running backs are also familiar with the force Lawrence can bring. “It’s just a nightmare. It’s just a big blob of nightmare.” Former New Orleans Saints running back Jamaal Williams stated. “Don’t even look at the A gaps. Duo, don’t run it. Nine out of 10 times (he’s) in the back field. That one time it’s probably because he’s just tired.”

Lawrence joins wide receiver Malik Nabers for Giants players listed on the NFL Top 100. Nabers made his NFL Top 100 debut at No. 67.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...lawrence-no-17-among-nfl-coms-top-100-players
 
Survey: How excited are you for the Giants in 2025?

Giants quarterback Russell Wilson signals for a touchdown against the New York Jets


We made it. The 2025 off-season and preseason are officially over.

The New York Giants have finished their cuts to trim the 90-man roster down to their 53-man roster and the next stop is Landover, Maryland, to face the Washington Commanders to start the 2025 season.

It’s been a long and eventful off-season for the Giants. Nine months ago, we weren’t sure whether Joe Schoen and the coaching staff would even have jobs for 2025. Not only did they retain their jobs (for the most part, anyway), but they’ve made a series of moves in free agency and the draft that could radically change the direction of the floundering franchise.

The Giants completely renovated the quarterback position by signing Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, as well as trading up to draft Jaxson Dart. They’ve also infused talent and leadership into every level of the defense by signing Paulson Adebo and Jevon Holland, as well as drafting Abdul Carter and Darius Alexander.

So now we have a pretty simple question for you as we get ready for Week 1: Are you excited?

There’s been a lot of discussion of a new energy around the facilities and a buzz amongst the fanbase. Are you feeling it, or do you think this year will be more of the same?

Secondly, we want to know how many games you think the Giants will win this year.

Vegas has set the Giants’ most likely win total at 6 on the season, and fans previously took the “over” on an over/under set at 5.5 wins.

The Giants are the eighth team since 2009 to outscore their opponents by 60 (or more) points in the preseason, which has historically correlated with a trip to the playoffs and the teams to accomplish that feat have averaged 11 wins. It’s worth noting that two of those teams were quarterbacked by Russell Wilson (the 2012 and 2013 Seahawks). Of course the last team to do it was the 2024 Chicago Bears, who only won 5 games last year.

So how many games do you think the Giants will win? Do you think they’ll win fewer than 5 games, roughly match Vegas’ predictions, or exceed everyone’s wildest dreams?

Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across the NFL. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in Giants fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/reacts/134013/survey-how-excited-are-you-for-the-giants-in-2025
 
Ex-Giant Tommy DeVito claimed by New England Patriots

gettyimages-2231811898.jpg


Tommy DeVito will not be returning to the New York Giants as a member of the team’s practice. DeVito was claimed on waivers Wednesday by the New England Patriots.

There was some hope that the popular DeVito, a New Jersey high school hero who authored an unlikely three-game winning streak as an undrafted free agent rookie quarterback in 2023, would go unclaimed and return to the Giants on the practice.

Instead, DeVito will back up Drake Maye in New England. Whether he will be QB2 or QB3 with the Patriots is unknown. New England also has veteran Joshua Dobbs on its 53-man roster.

DeVito, of course, lost his roster spot in New York because the Giants have a rebuilt quarterback room with veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, and first-round pick Jaxson Dart.

In two seasons with the Giants, DeVito went 3-5 as a starter. In 12 total games, he completed 145 of 222 passes for 1,358 yards with eight touchdowns and three interceptions.

The Giants are in Foxboro, Mass. to face the Patriots on Dec. 1. Could DeVito play against his old team?

Here is the question for you, Giants fans:

Are you happy for DeVito that he landed on another team’s 53-man roster, or bummed because he will no longer be a Giant?

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...-tommy-devito-claimed-by-new-england-patriots
 
New York Giants roster cuts tracker: Cuts, trades, rumors on the path to 53

gettyimages-2187918628.jpg

Montrell Washington (80) is the first reproted cut by the Giants.

With the 2025 NFL preseason in their rearview mirror, attention for the New York Giants now turns to constructing their initial 53-man roster. NFL teams have until Tuesday, Aug. 26 at 4 p.m. ET to set their 53-man rosters.

Follow this tracker, which will be constantly updated, as the Giants whittle their roster from the preseason limit of 90 players to 53.

Roster Moves​

Wednesday, Aug. 27​


Claimed off waivers:

Tuesday​


Final cuts announced by the Giants to set their initial 53-man roster:

Waived, No Recall:

WR Dalen Cambre

DL Elijah Chatman

QB Tommy DeVito

TE Greg Dulcich

DL Cory Durden

OLB Trace Ford

OLB Tomon Fox

DL Elijah Garcia

C Bryan Hudson

G Jake Kubas

S Raheem Layne

K Jude McAtamney

RB Dante Miller

C Jimmy Morrissey

S Makari Paige

DL Jordon Riley

WR Juice Wells Jr.

CB Dee Williams

Terminated, Vested Veteran, all contracts:

OT Stone Forsythe

WR Lil’Jordan Humphrey

DL Jeremiah Ledbetter

WR Ihmir Smith-Marsette

RB Jonathan Ward

Waived/Injured:

WR Da’Quan Felton

CB Tre Hawkins III

TE Jermaine Terry II

Reserve/Physically Unable to Perform:

OLB Victor Dimukeje

RB Eric Gray

Reserve/Injured/Designated for Return

OL Joshua Ezeudu



Tick … tick … tick …

Giants have nine remaining moves that haven't been reported to get down to 53. Three are clerical: RB Eric Gray and OLB Victor Dimukeje will shift to the PUP reserve list, sidelining them for at least the first four games. Also, K Jude McAtamney will be cut and then land back on…

— Dan Duggan (@DDuggan21) August 26, 2025

WR Juice Wells [Ranaan]

An undrafted free agent, Wells never really capitalized on having been a teammate of Jaxson Dart’s at Ole Miss.

WR/KR Ihmir Smith-Marsette [Ranaan]

Smith-Marsette did a really nice job returning punts and kickoffs last season. This has to mean the Giants are keeping Gunner Olszewski, the player Smith-Marsette replaced due to injury a season ago. Olszewski showed more ability as a receiver during the preseason. It may also be good news for undrafted free agent rookie Beaux Collins.

Whether or not Smith-Marsette can be a useful reserve wide receiver might be the crux of the issue:

The times I have played WR I showed what I can do just staying patient it’s all part of God’s plan!! 🙏🏾

— Ihmir Smith-Marsette (@ihmirsm) August 26, 2025

C/G Bryan Hudson [Ranaan]

Could land on the practice squad.

DL Elijah Garcia [Duggan]

Another cut that seemed inevitable as the Giants try to upgrade along the defensive line.

Edge Trace Ford [Ranaan]

An undrafted free agent, Ford had a good summer. He should land on the practice squad.

Report: Rookie TE Thomas Fidone will make the 53-man roster:

With Greg Dulcich let go (per @TomPelissero), seventh-round TE Thomas Fidone — he of the self-tattooing skills — has inked himself onto the #Giants’ 53-man roster, sources say. Fidone caught 8 of 9 targets for 64 yards in the preseason and showed strong blocking ability as well. pic.twitter.com/pmkyVo8EK5

— Mike Garafolo (@MikeGarafolo) August 26, 2025

I did not think the Giants would want to expose Fidone to waivers. Little chance he would pass through to the practice squad.

WR Lil’Jordan Humphrey [Schefter]

Not a big surprise. Humphrey made a few red zone catches in preseason, but he is a backup wide receiver who does not play special teams. That’s not a good combination.

While we wait for cuts, an interesting tidbit from Ryan Dunleavy:

Teams checked in with #Giants on availability Jalin Hyatt, Daniel Bellinger and Jameis Winston and were told then the plan is to keep them on 53-man roster, per sources

— Ryan Dunleavy (@rydunleavy) August 26, 2025

CB Dee Williams [Duggan]

Williams is more returner than cornerback, and that’s not something the Giants needed.

TE Greg Dulcich [Pelissero]

Dulcich had a great summer, but it wasn’t enough. That could be good news for Daniel Bellinger. That makes five misses for me on my 53-man roster projection. Expecting more at wide receiver and on the offensive line.

DL Elijah Chatman [Duggan]

I am stunned by this one. I thought he had enough value as a pass rusher, and that the fullback stuff he showed in preseason would lock down a spot for him. Guess not. I think that is four misses for me thus far on the 53 — Chatman, K’Von Wallace, Dante Miller, Tre Hawkins.

We won’t be seeing any of this against the Washington Commanders:

Giants are releasing one of the best two way players in sports Elijah Chatman per @DDuggan21

pic.twitter.com/mKhJYkRBZn

— Talkin’ Giants (@TalkinGiants) August 26, 2025

DL Cory Durden [Duggan]

This is another move that was expected. Durden was a fill-in at the end of last season, but never seemed likely to make this year’s 53-man roster.

CB Tre Hawkins [Duggan]

Hawkins was waived/injured after missing much of training camp. A sixth-round pick in 2023, he never lived up to the promise he showed in his rookie training camp.

S Makari Paige [Duggan]

An undrafted free agent, Paige seems like a practice squad candidate. And yes, it looks like Dan Duggan of The Athletic is crushing everybody in terms of getting the cuts first.

S Raheem Layne [Duggan]

It looks like the Giants will carry only three safeties on the initial 53-man roster. I would expect that to change.

RB Jonathan Ward [Duggan]

No surprise. He was only brought in recently to help the Giants get through the Cam Skattebo injury.

TE Jermaine Terry [Duggan]

An undrafted free agent rookie, Terry was waived/injured.

OL Jake Kubas [Duggan]

Kubas was an early favorite to make the 53-man roster after a good rookie season, but he struggled throughout the preseason.

Edge Tomon Fox [Duggan]

This is not a surprise. Fox had slid behind undrafted free agent rookie Trace Ford on the depth chart, and Ford is likely ticketed for the practice squad.

RB Dante “Turbo” Miller [Duggan]

Miller was a preseason star. That marks two players off my 53-man roster projection who have now been let go. Miller seems like a good practice squad candidate.

The Giants are releasing quarterback Tommy DeVito [Schultz]

I thought DeVito would generate some trade interest. Apparently not. [FULL STORY]



Here is a thread with some thoughts before Tuesday’s cuts begin:

Here is a thread of some thoughts before we start getting news of roster moves:– I was already wrong about safety K'Von Wallace. I'm thinking it isn't going to matter who gets the fourth safety spot today. The Giants will add a safety off the waiver wire.

Ed Valentine (@edvalentine.bsky.social) 2025-08-26T12:01:40.985Z

Sunday​


The Giants announced Sunday that S K’Von Wallace was cut [Announcement]

Wallace had experience with DC Shane Bowen at Tennessee, and it was thought that could be the Giants’ fourth safety.


Friday​


The Giants on Friday afternoon officially announced the release of the following eight players:

LB K.J. Cloyd

CB O’Donnell Fortune

An undrafted free agent, Fortune played well against the Patriots on Thursday and could be a practice squad candidate.

C Jimmy Morrissey

Morrissey spent last season on the Giants’ practice squad.

WR Zach Pascal

A seven-year veteran with 196 career receptions, the 30-year-old Pascal was trying to make the team primarily as a special teams contributor.

LB Dyontae Johnson [Ranaan]

Johnson had a great summer in 2024, but an ankle injury cost him most of the season. He couldn’t repeat that this summer.

WR Jordan Bly [Duggan]

OL Jaison Williams [Duggan]

Williams is an undrafted player out of Youngstown State who never really got any traction toward making the roster. Perhaps he could be a practice squad candidate.

WR Montrell Washington [Duggan]

Not surprised to see Washington let go. I was surprised to see his name as the first reported cut.

Other moves​


Cornerback T.J. Moore was placed on the injured reserve.

Moore suffered a broken femur in the final preseason game against the New England Patriots.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...-tracker-cuts-trades-rumors-on-the-path-to-53
 
Giants practice squad tracker 2025: Predictions, signings, analysis

Giants quarterback Tommy DeVito throws a pass against the New England Patriots in the third preseason game.

New York Giants quarterback Tommy DeVito throws a pass during the second half against the New England Patriots at MetLife Stadium.

The 2025 New York Giants finished the process of final cuts to set their 53-man roster on Tuesday afternoon. The next step in the process of building their team is signing players to their practice squad.

Teams can begin signing players to their practice squad at noon today, Wednesday, August 27th. In the past, practice squads were limited to 10 players with no more than two accrued seasons of experience. Now, however, practice squads have expanded to 17 players, with a couple caveats.

Six of the 17 spots are open to veterans with unlimited NFL experience, while one of the 17 spots is reserved for a player from the International Pathway program. The 17th player for the Giants will almost certainly be Irish kicker Jude McAtamney, unless he’s been claimed by a kicker-hungry team.

NFL teams can sign players off of any team’s practice squad to their active roster, however any team can also protect up to four players on their own practice squad, preventing another team from poaching them. Additionally, teams can elevate two practice squad players to the active roster on game days — though they can only do so twice in a season without signing them to the active roster.

2025 Practice squad signings​

  • WR Lil’Jordan Humphrey [Schefter] – Humphrey has good size and appeared to have a solid rapport with the Giants’ quarterbacks.
  • EDGE Trace Ford [Raanan] – Ford was impressive throughout the preseason with great explosion and hustle, just needs a bit more discipline in his rushes.
  • CB/KR Dee Williams [Duggan] – Williams gives them depth and developmental talent at multiple positions.
  • RB Dante Miller [Duggan] – Miller successfully passed through waivers after an(other) excellent preseason. Turbo sticks with the Giants.
  • iDL/FB Elijah Chatman [Duggan] – Chatman also returns to the Giants. The undersized pass rushing tackle (and fullback) remains an option for depth and a player to watch for 2026.
  • OL Jake Kubas [Duggan] – Kubas was promising in 2024, but struggled in the 2025 preseason. He’s a real candidate to make the roster in 2026 with another year of development.
  • EDGE Tomon Fox [Duggan] – Fox has hung around the periphery of the Giants’ EDGE unit for a while now, and will continue to do so. High effort player and a useful depth piece to keep around. He and Ford played well together.
  • iDL Elijah Garcia [Duggan] – Garcia couldn’t compete with the Giants’ upgraded defensive line depth, but he still played well when pressed into service by injury a year ago.
  • OL Bryan Hudson [Duggan] – Hudson couldn’t quite crack the final 53, but he offers more depth at the center position.
  • K Jude McAtamney [Duggan] – McAtamney will once again be the Giants’ international exemption. He couldn’t beat out Graham Gano, but still kicked well in the preseason.
  • S Raheem Layne [Duggan] – The Giants only have four safeties on their roster after claiming Beau Brade from the Ravens. Layne was the fourth safety throughout camp and gives them solid depth in the event of an emergency.
  • WR/KR Ihmir Smith-Marsette [Duggan / Joe Schoen] – The Giants 2024 returner returns to the practice squad. Depth behind Gunner Olszewski and a very useful player in his own right.
  • iDL Jordon Riley [Duggan / Joe Schoen] – Riley took over the Giants’ nose tackle job after Dexter Lawrence was injured last year. He didn’t rack up stats, but does a good job of occupying double teams to free up his teammates.

Note: It was initially reported that TE Greg Dulcich was signing with the Giants’ practice squad, however that has yet to be confirmed. We’ll update when we have clarity on the matter. The Giants currently sit at 12 practice squad players, plus Jude McAtamney as the International Pathway exemption.

Potential practice squad players

  • WR Dalen Cambre
  • WR Juice Wells
  • S Makari Paige

Potential veteran additions

  • OT Stone Forsythe

Of course, the Giants aren’t limited to the players who were on their 90-man roster, though those are the ones with whom they’re most familiar. They can sign any of the hundreds of players cut by the other 31 teams on Tuesday.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...ad-tracker-2025-predictions-signings-analysis
 
Giants waiver claim: CB Rico Payton added to 53-man roster

gettyimages-2171355605.jpg


The Giants used their No. 3 overall spot in the waiver priority order on Wednesday in an effort to upgrade their secondary. They claimed safety Beau Brade from the Baltimore Ravens and have also added cornerback Rico Payton, recently waived by the New Orleans Saints.

The 25-year-old Payton is a former undrafted free agent who played in 16 games for the Saints last season, almost exclusively on special teams. Rico played just 21 defensive snaps, but was on the field for 257 special teams snaps.

Payton, 6-foot, 182 pounds, played 47 defensive snaps for the Saints during the preseason. He was at wide cornerback on 43 of those, and in the slot for just one.

Payton played collegiately at Division II Pittsburgh State. He impressed while making the New Orleans roster a season ago, but could not hold on to his roster spot this time.

The Giants kept 10 defensive backs on their initial 53-man roster, seven cornerbacks and three safeties. We will update you whenever corresponding moves are made to make space for both Brade and Payton.

The Giants cut kick returner/wide receiver Gunner Olszewski and cornerback Korie Black, a seventh-round pick, to make room for Payton and Brade. Expect Olszewski back on the roster soon as this seems like roster gymnastics. Black is probably headed to the practice squad if he clears waivers.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...r-claim-cb-rico-payton-added-to-53-man-roster
 
Beau Brade claimed on waivers by New York Giants

gettyimages-2230161254.jpg


The New York Giants figured to add to their safety position via waivers or free agency after keeping only three on their initial 53-man roster. It appears they have done so, using their spot with the No. 3 overall waiver claim priority to claim former Baltimore Ravens safety Beau Brade.

Brade, 23, is a former undrafted free agent out of Maryland who played in 11 games for the Ravens in 2024. Brade played just 11 defensive snaps for the Ravens, but played 207 snaps on special teams.

Brade is listed at 6-foot, 209 pounds.

Here is a pre-2024 NFL Draft scouting report on Brade from The Draft Network:

Beau Brade is a multi-level defender with physicality that pops off the screen. Comfortable in a variety of coverages and has experience in single-high.

Against the run, Brade showcases a willingness to mix it up unlike any other safety in the class. Hunts for contact and approaches ball-carriers with intelligent violence to avoid whiffs and missed tackles. Can diagnose from depth and beat second-level defenders to the spot. Can, at times, overpurse due to his willingness to attack the alley, but he is rarely out of position (Ohio State). Consistently a part of the pile and isn’t afraid to attack linemen in space, either. Not an overpowering athlete to blow through blocks but has the requisite strength and athleticism to quickly disengage.

In coverage, Brade’s instincts showcase extremely well. Not a ton of work near the line of scrimmage in man, however. Comfortable in single and two-high as well as the robber working at the second level. High-level processor when playing centerfield. Excellent click-and-close ability and hand usage to work through the upper half of pass-catchers. Physicality pops in coverage and thrives inside a phone booth. Despite Brade’s comfortability in battling for space, he rarely will draw a flag and does not grab if caught off balance (three penalties in 1,713 career snaps). His potential as a hybrid second-level defender is through the roof due to his athleticism, tackling ability, and instincts.

Brade’s hips and footwork are smooth but top-end speed/acceleration is lacking to be a true numbers-to-numbers defender. Eyes can also get caught in the backfield on play-action (Ohio State/Michigan).

Overall, Brade is a well-rounded prospect who will impact a defense on all three downs. A future at free safety remains intriguing, but activation inside the box as a modern-day defensive chess piece could quickly see Brade become a high-level playmaker at the NFL level.

Here is a play from Blade during the 2024 preseason with the Ravens:

Excellent fit from the table (depth) by Ravens Safety Beau Brade.

He was the 4th in @FieldVisionMi's Safety Havoc Ratings this preseason & made the roster as an UDFA.
pic.twitter.com/tBw4snexnp

— Cody Alexander (@The_Coach_A) August 30, 2024

Here is Ravens coach John Harbaugh talking about Brade during training camp:

Former Terp Beau Brade, who’s entrenched in a battle for the Ravens third safety spot, has drawn the attention of Ravens head coach John Harbaugh:

Beau is flying around, he’s playing really well. He’s the first guy in the weight room in the morning.”

🎥: (wbffbaltimore/YouTube) pic.twitter.com/uJ86vHFyIa

— Inside Maryland Sports (@Terrapins247) July 31, 2025

The Giants cut kick returner/wide receiver Gunner Olszewski and cornerback Korie Black, a seventh-round pick, to make room for Brade and cornerback Rico Payton, who was also claimed on waivers. Expect Olszewski back on the roster soon as this seems like roster gymnastics. Black is probably headed to the practice squad if he clears waivers.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...u-brade-claimed-on-waivers-by-new-york-giants
 
5 things we learned from Joe Schoen, Brian Daboll

gettyimages-2227032482.jpg


New York Giants general manager Joe Schoen was not biting on Wednesday on the idea of putting expectations on the 2025 Giants, or comparing the current roster to the previous three he constructed as the team’s GM.

He was, though, happy to talk about the veteran leadership dotted across the team’s “evolving” 53-man landscape.

“One of the things that Dabs [Brian Daboll] and I tried to do early on and it’s just hard, it takes time, is we talk about leadership in every room,” Schoen said. “We’ve finally been able to add leadership in every room, and we feel good about the team leadership.

“I think that’s showed throughout the spring in training camp, the leadership, some of the veterans that we have, some of our own that have grown into leaders.

“I would say that’s one of the bigger differences that I’ve felt throughout this offseason.”

Schoen name-dropped a number of players, some new to the roster and others who have been with the team for a while, as adding to the leadership.

“Even a guy like Brian Burns, from last year to this year, the jump he’s made, and he’s been a tremendous leader this offseason,” Schoen said. “some of the off-season acquisitions that we brought in, Russ [Wilson] and Jameis [Winston] and Roy Robertson-Harris and [Jevon] Holland and Paulson [Adebo], true pros, true pros that have the DNA that we look for and covet. Again, the camaraderie, guys that love ball, guys that hold each other accountable, staying after, doing the extra.

I really like where they are right now, the way they’re approaching the season, and just the true aspect of the team feel that we have.“

Schoen also mentioned players like Bobby Okereke, Greg Van Roten, Jon Runyan and Devin Singletary as veteran leaders.

“The more of those guys you can have that are going to do things the right way and are unselfish and true pros, that can be contagious for some of the young players, and it can elevate everybody,” he said.

But, about those expectations​


Schoen said only “we’ll see” in terms of what type of team the Giants would be.

“We like the roster. We like the chemistry. We like the leadership,” Schoen said. “Now we’ve got to go out and do it on Sundays.

“We had a good training camp. We had a good spring. Now we’re two weeks away. We have to go out and do it. Do I like the team? Yes. I like the chemistry. I feel like we’ve been executing. We’ve had good practice. The guys have done a good job through camp. It’s been really good competition, and now it’s time to go out and do it.”

Tommy DeVito landing in New England​


The hope from the Giants fan base that quarterback Tommy DeVito would land on the team’s practice squad after losing his 53-man roster spot was dashed on Wednesday when he was claimed off waivers by the New England Patriots.

“We would have loved to have him back,” Schoen said. “He was claimed, and we wish him nothing but the best.”

The Giants will not have a practice squad quarterback at the beginning of the season.

“We’re just going to go with three for right now,” Schoen said.

The newbies​


The Giants were awarded safety Beau Brade [full story] and cornerback Rico Payton [full story] off waivers on Wednesday. Both Brade, formerly with the Baltimore Ravens, and Payton, formerly with the New Orleans Saints, are undrafted second-year players who played primarily on special teams in 2024.

Schoen said that Payton, said by scouting reports to be primarily a box safety, is a player the Giants were hoping the Saints would put on waivers last season.

“Last year during this time we were hoping, you hope some of these guys get cut and they end up making teams and playing,” Schoen said. “He’s a really good special teams player and we also think he has defensive value.”

Payton, 6-foot, 182 pounds, played 257 special teams snaps last season compared to only 21 on defense. He played collegiately at Division II Pittsburgh State.

Here is Schoen’s take on Brade:

“He’s a player that we spent some time with coming out of the draft and we liked,” Schoen said. “He played on special teams for them last year, also can be a depth safety for us.

“High character kid. Smart, tough, dependable. Checked all those boxes.”

Brade played just 11 defensive snaps for the Ravens, but played 207 snaps on special teams.

“We were just looking for good football players that could help us,” Schoen said. “Just to upgrade the depth of both of those positions. We were happy to get those guys.”

Tough days​


Some on the outside would look at the process of cutting the Giants’ roster from 90 players to 53 as more difficult than it has been in recent years due to the belief that the roster possesses more talent.

Daboll pushed back Wednesday on that idea.

“I’m not sure I’ve ever been in the league where it has [not] been a tough cut,” Daboll said. “Every player puts so much into it to try to be on a roster, and roughly 1,200 guys are out of a job come cut-down day. You bring 580, 600 back, whatever that may be. That means over 650 guys are out of the league right now.

“So every year is tough relative to releasing players … These last couple days are always kind of tough days.”

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...hings-we-learned-from-joe-schoen-brian-daboll
 
TE Greg Dulcich signs with the Dolphins’ practice squad

Tight end Greg Dulcich celebrates after scoring a touchdown against the New York Jets.

Greg Dulcich is joining the Miami Dolphins.

Former New York Giants tight end Greg Dulcich has signed with the Miami Dolphins, per reports.

Dulcich is coming off of a strong preseason performance with the Giants in which he caught 7 passes for 53 yards and 3 touchdowns. While his total yardage wasn’t impressive, Dulcich showed a good rapport with the Giants’ quarterbacks and was targeted in high-leverage situations.

Despite that his performance, the Giants released Dulcich in final cutdowns. The Giants have a (potentially) very strong tight end unit with Theo Johnson, Daniel Bellinger, Chris Manhertz, and Thomas Fidone II, and the team opted for more blocking upside at the expense of Dulcich’s receiving.

It was hoped that they’d be able to sign him to their practice squad, likely capitalizing on his relationship with Jaxson Dart in particular.

Instead, Dulcich seems to have opted for what could be a significantly easier path to the field in Miami. The Dolphins have Tanner Conner, Julian Hill, and (former Giant) Darren Waller at tight end. While Waller is a former Pro Bowl player, neither Conner nor Hill have produced much in their respective careers and have a combined 21 receptions on 35 career targets.

We could see the former third-round pick on the field sooner rather than later.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...ulcich-signs-with-the-dolphins-practice-squad
 
Giants news, 8/28: Tommy DeVito a Patriot, Joe Schoen, Dexter Lawrence, more headlines

imagn-26692170.jpg


Good morning, New York Giants fans!

From Big Blue View​

Other Giant observations​

Five Takeaways From Giants Training Camp | SI.com

The optimism here starts, interestingly enough, with the quarterback room. I’ll admit I was skeptical on how Russell Wilson, Jameis Winston and a highly drafted rookie (wound up being Jaxson Dart) would coalesce when this started to come together in March. By all accounts, Wilson’s been good thus far in being a vocal leader in the meeting room and on the practice field, setting the bar as far as preparation, work ethic and the overall level of expectation. Winston’s personality and experience have been a nice complement to Wilson’s…and Dart’s soaking everything up—and is everything the Giants expected him to be thus far. So how will it look on the field? Wilson seems energized by the coaches’ buy-in on him, and Brian Daboll’s building an offense to lean into what he does well, in an effort to get him playing fast with the ball coming out quickly. As for Dart, there is some carryover in what the staff is building for Wilson, and what it’ll look like whenever the rookie takes over, be it at some point this year or next. All of this, of course, has to come together on the field, and the Giants feel good about that happening.

Joe Schoen: Dart has “a lot of room for growth”​

"The timeline will be the timeline, however it works out."

Joe Schoen was asked about the timeline for Jaxson Dart to potentially become the Giants' starting quarterback after Schoen complimented Dart's ability to execute the playbook so quickly: pic.twitter.com/CRPraEvzQI

— Giants Videos (@SNYGiants) August 27, 2025

Stock up, stock down for rookies after the 2025 NFL preseason | PFF


Stock Up: QB Jaxson Dart, New York Giants. Russell Wilson will be the Week 1 starter for the Giants, and likely continue in that role until he falters or New York falls out of contention. However, first-rounder Jaxson Dart made things interesting with his outstanding performance this preseason.

Dart’s 88.5 PFF passing grade across three outings led all rookies and ranked second among all qualifiers. His penchant for vertical completions and making throws under pressure both showed up often. Dart is far more likely to see playing time in the regular season than he was a month ago.

2025 NFL Rookie Quarterbacks: Projected Stats for Cam Ward, Jaxson Dart, Others Who Could Struggle | SI.com

Overall thoughts: The only two logical places to drop Dart into the 2025 season are on the road in Week 5 against the Saints and after the team’s very late bye in Week 14. Of course, something could happen in practice that showcases Dart’s superiority to Russell Wilson and the change could be made organically, but that’s how I came up with 13 starts. I think Dart will have a kind of Carson Wentz–y rookie season, which means a lot of really cool pocket evasions, with some big throws downfield and, sure, a couple of head-scratchers in between. I also think that, like Wentz, Dart will have his own kind of offense that runs at a different pace and style that may help make the Giants carve out an advantage against overmatched opponents.

Inside the reimagined high-profile Giants QB room | ESPN.com


Winston is the ultimate character. You never quite know what he’s going to say or do. Wilson is much more predictable. He’s the buttoned-up veteran beaming with optimism and serious about his business. Dart is the young first-round pick overflowing with aura. It’s quite the mix of backgrounds and personalities all deeply invested in the others’ success.

“It’s a really fun room to be a part of because it’s super competitive that way,” Dart said. “We have an amazing relationship between all of us. It’s definitely fun. We’re all each other’s biggest fans when we’re on the field.”

Orlovsky: Dart’s skills showed in preseason​

Traits and skills transferring quickly from CFB to the @NFL is always good for QBs.@Giants QB Dart doing just that…#NFLLive pic.twitter.com/B7oNGEcEjJ

— Dan Orlovsky (@danorlovsky7) August 26, 2025

2025 NFL triplets rankings, 1-32: Ravens, Lions lead top QB/RB/pass catcher trios | NFL.com


27. New York Giants. Quarterback: Jaxson Dart, Running back: Tyrone Tracy Jr., Pass catcher: Malik Nabers

Yes, I’m aware Russell Wilson is the starting quarterback. No, I don’t think that will remain the case all season. Frankly, given the Giants’ brutal schedule — which carries the highest opponent 2024 win percentage in the league — I’ll be surprised if Jaxson Dart isn’t QB1 by Halloween. The first-round pick didn’t light the league on fire in the preseason, but he definitely showed promise. More importantly, Brian Daboll demonstrated the ability to meld college concepts into his scheme, giving the rookie the kind of easy-button throws that’ll smooth his transition into the NFL. And most importantly, this is a critical season for Daboll and Joe Schoen, considering owner John Mara stated that he’s “just about run out of patience” when he announced in January that the coach and general manager would be back in 2025. If the rookie quarterback displays competence alongside second-year pros Tyrone Tracy Jr. and Malik Nabers, the youth movement could be this regime’s lifeline to 2026 and beyond.

2025 NFL bold predictions: Potential surprises for 32 teams | ESPN.com


Don’t be surprised if … the Giants lead the league in sacks.

What I’m hearing: Word out of Giants camp is Abdul Carter is everything the team believed him to be when it made him the third pick in this year’s draft. Adding Carter to a defensive front that already features Brian Burns, Dexter Lawrence II and Kayvon Thibodeaux should give the Giants one of the more fearsome and tireless pass rushes in the entire NFL. The defense up front should be the team’s strength, and it could be enough to propel the Giants to a few surprise wins against their tough-looking schedule — especially if they can generate turnovers and give the offense some short fields. New York tied for eighth in sacks last season with 45.

New York Giants announce Season Kickoff Event presented by Verizon | Giants.com


The New York Giants will kick off the 2025 season with a free and open to the public fan event, presented by Verizon, in American Dream on Friday, September 5, starting at 2:00 p.m. Admission to the Giants kickoff event is free, but fans must reserve a ticket to attend the main stage portion of the event from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. The event will feature a Giants Fan Zone with a live DJ, autographs and Q&A with Giants Legends, and Kids Zone packed with youth activities, face painting, photo opportunities with the Super Bowl trophy, and more.

WFAN’s “Evan & Tiki Show” is set to take the main stage from 2:00 p.m. to 6:30 p.m. with a special live broadcast. The excitement continues into the evening on the main stage with players scheduled to appear, including Russell Wilson, Tyrone Tracy, Malik Nabers, Jevón Holland, Brian Burns, and Kayvon Thibodeaux. The players will preview the upcoming season on a panel hosted by Madelyn Burke and Brandon London.

Around the league​


Report: Cowboys pass rusher Micah Parsons seeking second opinion on back issue | Blogging the Boys

Ravens’ Kyle Hamilton signing four-year extension worth over $100M to become highest-paid safety | NFL.com

NFL remains mum on impact of Jim Harbaugh’s NCAA “show cause” order | Pro Football Talk

Adam Thielen returns to Vikings in trade with Panthers | ESPN.com

Jaguars acquiring WR Tim Patrick in trade with Lions | The Athletic

Dolphins GM Chris Grier admits Miami going through ‘reset’ of contracts and money: ‘It’s just not sustainable’ | CBSSports.com

BBV mailbag​


Have a Giants-related question? E-mail it to [email protected] and it might be featured in our weekly mailbag.

BBV YouTube​


You can find and subscribe to Big Blue View YouTube from the show’s home page


BBV on X: Follow @BigBlueView | Ed Valentine: @Valentine_Ed | Threads: @ed.valentine | Bluesky: @edvalentine

BBV on Facebook: Click here to like the Big Blue View Facebook page

BBV on YouTube: Subscribe to the Big Blue View YouTube channel

BBV on Instagram: Click here to follow our Instagram page

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...iot-joe-schoen-dexter-lawrence-more-headlines
 
Malik Nabers growing into leadership role for Giants

gettyimages-2231508166.jpg

Malik Nabers

As the New York Giants prepare for their season opener against the Washington Commanders next Sunday, wide receiver Malik Nabers is stepping into a bigger role both on and off the field.

Heading into his second season, the 2024 first-round pick said he trying to be more vocal in the locker room.

“It’s not natural, personally, but sometimes you have to step out of your comfort zone,” he said. “If we want everything to go right this season, your best players have to do those things.”

A major focus for Nabers has been building chemistry with new quarterback Russell Wilson. He described spending extensive time with Wilson this offseason, both on and off the field, to strengthen their connection.

“We’ve been on the same page a lot. That connection’s going to keep growing,” Nabers said. “When your quarterback is able to pick apart a defense as good as Russ is, it makes the receiver job a whole lot easier.”

Beyond the X’s and O’s, Nabers has been learning from Wilson’s leadership and professionalism.

“He’s an amazing person, amazing father. His family is amazing. He has the right people around him that keep him going,” Nabers said. “Being around him is that early process I’m taking as a young man, trying to pick up little pieces to help me grow as a person and as a man.”

Nabers dealt with a toe injury that kept him out of practice in the spring, and then minor shoulder and back issues that interrupted his practice time during training camp. He vowed to be ready for the season-opener against the Washington Commanders, though.

“I feel like I’m always ready,” Nabers said. “When it’s game time with those lights on, I believe my body is going to turn it on. He’s going to be ready to roll.”

Looking ahead to the season, Nabers kept it simple:

“We’re looking to win some games. That’s all I can say — I’m looking to win some games.”

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...abers-growing-into-leadership-role-for-giants
 
Film breakdown:What Beau Brade offers the Giants

imagn-24018924.jpg

Beau Brade with the Ravens.

The New York Giants claimed former Baltimore Ravens’ safety, Beau Brade, off waivers on Wednesday. The 6-foot, 209-pound Brade is a former Maryland Terrapin — similar to someone we all know well (Ed Valentine) — and was teammates with Deonte Banks in college.

Brade went undrafted in 2024 but had a productive college career. In 42 games, he recorded 177 tackles, 10 for a loss, a sack, three interceptions, and 11 pass break-ups, with three forced fumbles. Most of his production came in his final two seasons at College Park.

Beau Brade participated in the 2024 Reese’s Senior Bowl and the NFL Scouting Combine, although he didn’t test at the Combine. He measured at the 34th percentile for height, the 35th percentile for weight, and had a 64th percentile wing span (77 inches). His arms were 31 inches (27th percentile), and his hands were 10⅛ inches (92nd percentile).

At his Pro Day, Brade ran 4.68 in the 40-yard dash with a 1.58 10-yard split and a 4.31 short-shuttle. His three cone was an impressive 6.89 seconds (71st percentile), and he jumped 32.5 inches in the vertical and ten feet in the broad. Brade benched 225 pounds (the standard for testing )15 times.

Brade latched onto the Ravens as a local free agent in 2024, and he appeared in two regular-season games, totaling three tackles, with additional snaps on special teams. He had seven tackles and a PBU in the preseason, but Baltimore’s loaded defensive back room made him a prime practice squad candidate for Eric DeCosta. The Giants, however, had other plans.

Safety was a likely candidate for the Giants to explore with their third overall waiver priority. The Giants waived both Raheem Layne and Makari Paige at cutdown, with Jevon Holland, Tyler Nubin, and Dane Belton as the safeties on the roster.

The Giants were familiar with the 23-year-old former Baltimore Ravens. Joe Schoen had this to say:

“He’s a player that we spent some time with coming out of the draft, and we liked… High-character kid. Smart, tough, dependable. Checked all those boxes.”

Before we get into a few individual plays, I wanted to show a highlight reel of Brade’s All-22 tape through his young career:

The #Giants claimed Beau Brade off waivers from the #Ravens. Highlights below 🔽🔽🔽

A physical presence with quality tackles in space, pursuit, and while sifting through trash.

I can see why the Giants wanted to add him to their 53-man roster. pic.twitter.com/DVgVtXtigZ

— Nick Falato (@nickfalato) August 28, 2025

What impresses​


On tape, Beau Brade shows flashes that suggest he could handle multiple responsibilities, though those instances are limited. What stands out more consistently is his presence in the box:

View Link

Right side of screen, No. 25

I enjoy how Brade tempoed his path into contact here, which put No. 88 in a two-versus-one situation. Once the tight end climbed and Brade confirmed the football’s location in the arms of the running back, he leveraged his quick closing burst to tackle the back at the line of scrimmage — a nice, LOW, physical tackle. Brade quickly filled and the wide receiver had no chance of inserting himself into the play to help the tight end with his unfortunate decision.

View Link

In box safety over No. 44 — he is No. 6

Again, we see the quick decision off a singleback run where Brade read the split-zone movement from No. 44 and quickly penetrated the open B-Gap before the wide receiver could crack him. The tackle/guard COMBO had the near linebacker to worry about, so Brade took the initiative to help blow the play up at the line of scrimmage.

View Link

Safety in the screen, No. 6

Brade does well when square and coming forward, although I wish he would wrap up more. The Packers run a double-Y pitch, and Brade just quickly fills the C-Gap to earn a tackle for a loss: massive style points, though.

View Link
View Link

Deep MOFC safety who enters the screen, No. 6

This is a quality fit from depth — Brade is 15 yards off the football and took steps back and toward the outside boundary receiver. Still, he was able to come downhill and adjust to the running back’s path to make an open field tackle in the red zone. This is not an easy thing to do — wrap up, though!

View Link

Near LOS to the right, No. 6

Brade takes NO NONSENSE on this block against an in-line Packers’ wide receiver. The receiver was not ready, as Brade exploded — low to high — with tight elbows that provided a firm jolt. Brade then quickly located the ball carrier and disengaged the block to make the tackle.

View Link

Right side of screen, No. 24

Backside pursuit in the box is another aspect of Brade’s game that stands out on tape; not just because he’s physical, but it’s his ability to slightly and subtly tempo his path to avoid blocks and trash. He’s spatially aware in that regard. Brade is also quick to target once diagnosed — something that offenses may try to scheme against. It was also a good overall job by the Ravens to bottle up the run.

We saw several plays around the line of scrimmage — some in the box, some in pursuit — and a couple plays from depth as well. He also showed some good processing in coverage on the play below:

View Link

Deep middle fourth, No 25

The Ravens ran Cover-6 against a familiar face (Daniel Jones), and Brade was the deep middle fourth defender. The field-side receivers were clearout routes with an inward lean, and the Colts had a condensed stack to the boundary. Indianapolis wanted to clear out the outside deep fourth and have tight end Will Mallory (86) get behind the underneath zone defenders into an open cleared space, but Brade played this well.

The Colts ran the No. 2 toward the middle of the field to draw Brade’s attention. The receiver was rerouted inward and could have done a better job of distracting Brade, to be frank. Still, the young safety saw the route concept and understood the vacated place in zone due to the outside clearout and the back-side drag occupying the underneath defenders. Brade caused some initial consternation from Jones due to his positioning, but Jones stepped up and threw it anyway, but the new Giants’ defensive back helped swat the ball away. Very good and savvy play by Brade.

Needs improvement​


Brade has a physical presence in the box, but it’s not always imposing. He relies too often on throwing his shoulder into the target and doesn’t consistently wrap up. His tackling mechanics could be refined.

View Link

Safety from right of screen, No. 6

Brade flies in from a two-high shell to make a tackle on the cut-back by Emanuel Wilson (31). However, Brade fails to affect Wilson much as the running back embraces for contact. It wasn’t a big deal because another Raven was waiting for Wilson, but securing to the ground would have saved a yard or two and would have prevented a missed tackle on the resume of Brade.

The Maryland safety had a high rate of missed tackles in college. NBC Sports noted that he had a 19% missed tackle rate (didn’t specify if that was one season or more). He appears too wild into the tackle point at times.

Brade went for the wrap-up against the Eagles in this 2024 preseason play, but could not secure the tackle, which — again — was to the side of the runner.

View Link

Right side of screen, No. 6

Brade is adequate as an athlete, but he lacks difference-making athletic traits, which require him to exercise precise angles of attack.

View Link

Linebacker position to the right of screen, No. 6

Brade is protecting the C-Gap inside the tight end, who is in a wide split off the play-action fake toss to the field (his side). The Green Bay Packers roll out the quarterback toward Brade and send two receivers toward him to create leverage for Brade’s assignment, the running back. By the time Brade works through the traffic in man coverage, Wilson is off and running into the flats; Brade took a poor angle once he cleared the traffic, and the result was a significant gain for Green Bay.

View Link

Center field, No. 24

This was Week 18 against the Cleveland Browns, and Jerry Jeudy (3) made a fantastic move to get outside against Brade. I am not insinuating that this is Brade’s fault — he is not the contain defender, and an alley opened up that he filled. I’m more so including this play to showcase that, with a challenging situation, Brade’s athletic ability fails to bail him out, and he’s a few steps from tracking Jeudy down from the numbers to the sideline off the angle he took after he was put into a bad situation.

View Link

Top of screen safety, No. 6

The Ravens sent a massive blitz that left Brade alone against the No. 2 receiver on this third-and-nine. Brade was slow to close width, lost his balance, and fell, which allowed the receiver to secure a touchdown. Man coverage may be an issue, although his angles did appear to improve in the 2025 preseason.

Final thoughts​


As you can see, many of the negative plays were from his 2024 preseason as a rookie, wearing the No. 6. Here are some plays surrendered from the 2025 preseason where, yes, he allowed the catches, but his movement appears more crisp and his angles are better judged:

View Link

Top of screen safety, No. 25

View Link

Bottom of screen curl/flat defender that starts near LOS, No. 25

Brade is still 23 years old, and Schoen raved about his work ethic and character. It is plausible that the young man has rectified some of his struggles from a season ago. He does display impressive short-area quickness and explosiveness around the line of scrimmage. Still, fluidity when transitioning and his long speed will likely only be adequate.

I like the addition for depth and special teams purposes. There’s potential for development if he can focus on his tackling mechanics and become more reliable in that department because he’s flashed talent near the box. He may carve out a role in sub-packages and battle Dane Belton for snaps early. Overall, I understand why the Giants made this claim.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...lm-breakdownwhat-beau-brade-offers-the-giants
 
Canadian QB Taylor Elgersma working out for Giants, per report

gettyimages-2232247260.jpg


New York Giants general manager Joe Schoen said on Wednesday that the would not carry a quarterback on their practice squad, going with the three they have on the active roster — Russell Wilson, Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston.

That, though, is apparently not stopping them from assessing their options. The Giants are reportedly working out Canadian quarterback Taylor Elgersma on Thursday.

Elgersma, a 6-foot-3, 227-pound 23-year-old, was reportedly the first Canadian quarterback ever invited to the Senior Bowl after winning the Hec Crighton Trophy, Canada’s equivalent to the Heisman Trophy, in 2024 while leading Wilfrid Laurier University to a Vanier Cup appearance. The Vanier Cup is the trophy awarded to the team that wins the Canadian college football championship.

Elgersma went undrafted, but signed with the Green Bay Packers after a rookie minicamp tryout. He completed 16 of 23 passes for 166 yards with one touchdown and no interceptions during the preseason with the Packers, recording a 104.6 QB rating.

Here are some Elgersma Senior Bowl highlights:


Here is more about Elgersma’s Senior Bowl experience.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...or-elgersma-working-out-for-giants-per-report
 
Are the New York Giants the NFC’s X-factor?

New York Giants quarterback Russell Wilson celebrates with teammates after a first quarter touchdown against the New England Patriots.

Giants quarterback Russell Wilson celebrates after a touchdown.

The New York Giants have been widely dismissed this year.

The 2025 season is already being chalked up as another lost one for the Giants. Pundits across the NFL media landscape are talking about this year in terms of marking time until Jaxson Dart starts and whether or not Brian Daboll can save his job.

That, in and of itself, is an improvement over how they were being discussed to start 2025. At first, there was confusion as to how John Mara could justify keeping Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll. And then the selection of Dart was viewed as a desperate over-drafting of a quarterback who was the product of a gimmicky college offense.

It’s largely taken as a given that the Giants will be bad. Even fielding a Top 5 defense won’t be enough to make them relevant, let alone save them against a Murderer’s Row of a schedule.

For instance, Austin Mock of The Athletic is projecting the Giants to have the second-worst record in the NFC, leading only the New Orleans Saints. Mock’s model projects the Giants to win 5.6 games, with just a 4.6 percent chance of even making the playoffs.

Mock says about the Giants:

“Lastly, the Giants round out the division. Though we likely won’t see him to start the season, Jaxson Dart is the future at quarterback, and while throwing to star receiver Malik Nabers should make his life easier, I don’t have high hopes for this offense, no matter who is playing QB. However, I do think the defense, especially the line, could make offenses dread facing the Giants this season. Dexter Lawrence, Brian Burns and first-round pick Abdul Carter is about as good as it gets rushing the passer.”

Things don’t really get better for the Giants if we look at the NFC and AFC holistically. Of the AFC teams, only the Browns come in below the Giants with 5.4 projected wins.

That’s one fewer win than the Panthers, two fewer than the Bears, Colts, and Raiders, and three fewer than the Steelers.

But are the models accurate?

One of the, if not the, biggest reasons why offensive output is more consistent from year to year and predictive of future performance is the quarterback position. Quarterback production is usually pretty stable from year to year, and there usually isn’t as much turnover at the position as there is at other positions. Frankly, if teams have a quarterback that they think they can win with (or win because of), they’re loathe to move on from them.

It makes sense to have low expectations for the Giants’ offense in 2025 when they’ll (probably) return 10 of 11 starters from last year’s offense. But it’s that one position with a new starter that could be throwing the models for a loop.

I can’t comment on Mock’s models without knowing how they’re built. For all I know he did build in a way to relatively accurately project Russell Wilson into the Giants’ offense and then run the models based off of that.

But more broadly speaking, the sentiment seems to be that since the Giants’ offense was bad the last two years, it will be bad again. The logic, as it goes, is that the offensive line was bad, the passing game was anemic and inefficient, and they couldn’t score points.

And that is a pretty accurate assessment of the Giants over the last two years. But it does also leave out some fairly important context.

The Giants’ offensive line was thrown into a blender by injuries in each of the last two years, with back-ups starting at multiple positions and starters often out of position. It’s almost impossible to field even average play under those conditions and treating that as the baseline expectation simply has to introduce a measure of bias.

Likewise, the Giants were inefficient and anemic because much of their passing offense took place within five yards of the line of scrimmage. Those passes generally don’t lead to scoring opportunities, and they typically allow defenses to play downhill, swarming to the football and limiting yards after contact.

All that said, there were outliers in 2023 and 2024, exceptions to the rule that should raise some eyebrows. Most notable are the Giants’ second half comeback win over the Arizona Cardinals in 2023 and their 45-point outburst against the Indianapolis Colts last year. There were also plays that didn’t get made during the season when the Giants had vertical attacks schemed up, but opportunities weren’t taken. Daboll’s obvious frustration in those moments is a pretty clear clue that they wanted to be more aggressive than they were on a down-to-down basis.

This is what makes the Giants unpredictable in 2025. Yes, most of their offensive personnel is unchanged, but the seismic shift at the quarterback position could change everything.

We’ve seen them be more aggressive and explosive throughout the preseason, at times making a point of attacking deep. And considering teams often use preseason games to work on specific elements, the occasional emphasis on explosiveness at the expense of more methodical gains could be significant.

The Giants play two divisional opponents to start the season. They should be extremely familiar with the Giants, but even they can’t be sure of what they’ll get. A healthy offensive line and a philosophic shift on offense could well catch the Commanders and Cowboys off guard.

There usually isn’t much difference between the top and the bottom in the NFL, not like there is in college, which is why we can see “worst to first” leaps every year. That’s why teams are constantly searching for every possible advantage to leverage over their opponents. And we’ve already seen the Giants’ coaching staff use the element of surprise to great effect back in 2022.

If the Giants’ offense can be merely competent, the fact that there’s limited tape on the starters with Russell Wilson at quarterback could be a significant advantage. After all, the offensive line was league-average before injuries took their toll, Malik Nabers is a burgeoning star, and the rest of the skill position players aren’t wanting for talent.

An unpredictable offense is a dangerous one, and a defense that can swarm is dangerous in and of itself. The combination of factors could make the Giants’ defense even more dangerous than it appears on paper.

Final thoughts​


I’m not going to move off of my prediction of a 6-11 season for the Giants, at least not yet.

Yes, vibes are strong after a dominant preseason, and there’s some evidence that the Giants could be significantly better than expected.

I do believe that their ceiling is significantly higher than they’re getting credit, and they have the potential to surprise a lot of people this year. I also stand by my prediction that the Giants will be the team that nobody wants to play by the end of the year. In that way I do believe they could be like the 2022 Detroit Lions

They’ll probably be unpredictable to start the year, and that gives them an advantage until teams start to compile enough tape to learn their tendencies.

But even so, I also don’t think that the games they win will be the result of lucky breaks or smoke and mirrors. I think the Giants are close to reaching a critical mass of talent in its prime that they can be consistently competitive because of the guys on the field.

The question I keep coming back to as we’ve watched and analyzed the Giants’ moves in free agency in the draft, how they’ve developed over the summer, is “why not the Giants?”

And it’s a question that never seems to get answered in any kind of detail.

I’ve analyzed far too much football and seen too much of the Giants over the years to count my chickens before I even know if they’re chicken eggs. But at the same time, nobody has had a solid read on the Giants since the 2024 season ended.

  • Wholesale changes were expected in the coaching staff — that didn’t happen.
  • They were expected to splurge on big-name and aging free agents to save their jobs — that didn’t happen.
  • Nobody had a clue what the Giants’ strategy was for the draft and insiders league-wide got panicked looks when asked directly.
  • They were expected to be milquetoast and incompetent in the preseason. Instead they were dominant.

So I’m not going to say that the Giants will be good, any more than I can say that they will be bad. But I do think it’s a reasonable expectation for them to be an X-factor. People who make a living out of speaking authoritatively don’t like to say “I don’t know,” but I think it’s important to admit when you don’t know something. And I don’t think anyone has a good handle on what the Giants will be this year.

Yes, they have a daunting schedule, but it’s also possible that their opponents will eventually look at looming games against the Giants and feel more than a little trepidation.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-york-giants-news/133790/are-the-new-york-giants-the-nfcs-x-factor
 
New York Giants name 5 captains

gettyimages-2226838254.jpg


Wide receiver Darius Slayton has been named one of five 2025 captains for the New York Giants, a first-time honor for a player who is entering his seventh season as a Giant after being selected in Round 5 of the 2019 NFL draft.

Joining Slayton will be quarterback Russell Wilson, defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence, edge defender Brian Burns and inside linebacker Bobby Okereke. Interestingly, no special teams players were designated as captains.

Head coach Brian Daboll said players were asked to vote individually for five players.

Lawrence, along with Slayton one of the team’s two longest-tenured players, has been voted a captain each season since 2023.

Okereke has now been selected as a captain in each of his three seasons with the Giants since signing as a free agent.

Burns is in his second year with the Giants. GM Joe Schoen went out of his way on Wednesday to credit Burns with having been “a tremendous leader this offseason.”

Wilson, entering his 14th NFL season, is in his first season with the Giants.

Darius Slayton says he was surprised to be a named a captain this season, but he's grateful to his teammates for voting for him pic.twitter.com/M2Fo8T0sa2

— Giants Videos (@SNYGiants) August 28, 2025

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-york-giants-news/134252/new-york-giants-name-5-captains
 
Internet laughing at Cowboys as Jerry Jones trades Micah Parsons to Packers

gettyimages-2231007165.jpg


The Dallas Cowboys are stunningly trading All-Pro linebacker Micah Parsons to the Green Bay Packers, per Adam Schefter and others.

Per Schefter, the Packers and Parsons have already agreed to a four-year, $188 million contract with $120 million guaranteed. That makes Parsons the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history.

Parsons posted this on ‘X’:

Thank you Dallas ….. GO Pack Go! 🧀🟢🟡 pic.twitter.com/FBnN1zRIri

— Micah Parsons (@MicahhParsons11) August 28, 2025

Giants fans might feel the same way … at least with the first part.

Here is a quick list from Schefter of what Parsons accomplished in Dallas since being the 12th pick in the 201 NFL Draft:

  • Four-time Pro Bowler
  • Three-time All-Pro
  • Defensive Rookie of the Year
  • 52.5 sacks
  • 9 forced fumbles

The folks at Acme Packing Company, SB Nation’s Packers website, are already celebrating the news. The folks at Blogging The Boys, covering the Cowboys, are in disbelief.

Keep dropping by both sites to see how the two fan bases process this monumental trade.

Parsons, of course, has been seeking a new contract. Dallas owner/GM Jerry Jones overplayed his hand, and has now ended up weakening the Cowboys by trading away a 26-year-old who might be the best defensive player in football.

Per Schefter, the Cowboys got defensive tackle Kenny Clark and a pair of first-round picks in return.

The Internet is laughing​

Jerry Jones: I Have a plan for signing Micah Parsons

The Plan: pic.twitter.com/Be3BYMnpI7

— Pardon My Take (@PardonMyTake) August 28, 2025
To be honest, I don’t wanna hear anything about multiple first round picks and a player to the Cowboys. You can go four straight years with first round picks and not find a player as impactful as Micah Parsons.

— Art Stapleton (@art_stapleton) August 28, 2025
Caleb Williams seeing the Micah Parsons news

pic.twitter.com/Yj4LCyGqQ3

— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) August 28, 2025
POV: Micah Parsons got traded to the Packers while we were live on the air pic.twitter.com/AYozu0uK1d

— First Things First (@FTFonFS1) August 28, 2025
Dallas Cowboys fans walking into the gaff to news that Jerry Jones has traded Micah Parsons… pic.twitter.com/yvVxpUjpzj

— Jaja (@JajaBreed) August 28, 2025

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...las-cowboys-send-all-pro-to-green-bay-packers
 
Giants’ Andrew Thomas doesn’t sound like he believes he will play Week 1

gettyimages-1922660107.jpg


New York Giants left tackle Andrew Thomas, entrenched in a lengthy rehab process from Lisfranc surgery in the middle of the 2024 season, remains uncertain whether or not he will be able to play in the Sept. 7 season-opening game against the Washington Commanders.

“I’m not sure yet,” Thomas said while seated in the Giants’ locker room on Thursday. “I haven’t really done a ton of reps. I’ve done some indy (individual drills), took some one-on-one reps. I’m just trying to progress slowly, so we’ll see. But like I said, I’m not making any projections right now.

“I’m just trying not to give myself a deadline. Obviously, I want to be back, but if I don’t feel comfortable to be able to perform at the level I think I can, I don’t think it makes sense for me to be out there.”

Thomas’s medical issues this past offseason went beyond what had been previously reported:

Thomas told me had another surgery in April to have the screw removed from his foot. The screw had been inserted during the initial surgery in October. Thomas said doctors told him at the time it was 50/50 if the screw would need to be removed. His was removed because it was… https://t.co/nDMOagWoKT

— Dan Duggan (@DDuggan21) August 28, 2025

Thomas was taken off the Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) list just two days before the preseason finale against the New England Patriots. He has yet to do any 11-on-11 work, and Wednesday was his first padded practice. Following that padded practice, he appeared to have a lighter workload on Thursday.

Thomas said he was “not bad” physically after Wednesday’s practice.

“Every time you go out there and do something new, there’s some soreness that comes with that,” Thomas said. “But I responded pretty well, and I’m feeling good today. And then I’ll get on the field tomorrow to do some more running. I know everybody else is off, but that’s just the plan that they have for me right now, to get some extra stuff on Friday and keep progressing.”

"I want to be back, but if I don't feel comfortable to be able to perform at the level I think I can, I don't think it makes sense for me to be out there"

Andrew Thomas talks about when he hopes to return to the field: pic.twitter.com/vtHSY8pZ1v

— Giants Videos (@SNYGiants) August 28, 2025

Thomas, the fourth overall pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, was a second-team All-Pro in 2022. His career has been marred by lower-body injuries, though.

During his first couple of seasons, he dealt with ankle injuries that were finally dealt with surgically. He missed seven games in 2023 with a hamstring injury. In 2024, the Lisfranc injury cost him 11 games.

Thomas admitted Thursday that the Lisfranc rehab has been “a tough recovery.”

Thomas said there will always be some pain in the surgically-repaired foot that he will need to manage, but he is trying to learn the difference between normal, OK soreness and something more alarming.

“I’ve talked to different doctors, different surgeons that have different opinions. I think part of it, coming back from an injury like this, there will be some soreness that you have to manage and get through,” Thomas said. “My biggest concern is making sure I can’t make it worse or re-injure it, so I’m just trying to take my time, stick with the plan that they’re giving me, and see where it goes.”

Thomas said he has used former Giant Shaun O’Hara, who dealt with a similar injury during his career, as a resource.

“It’s just a tough injury for heavier guys,” Thomas said. “You’ll have projections of when they think you’ll be back, but for bigger guys, a lot of times it just takes longer, and that’s what he [O’Hara] said. It took him nine or ten months to get through some of the pain and stuff, and throughout the season he dealt with some stuff too.”

The Giants need the best version of Thomas they can get, whenever they can get it. On Thursday, Thomas did not sound like a player who will be on the field Week 1.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...nt-sound-like-he-believes-he-will-play-week-1
 
Gunner Olszewski returns in series of Giants roster moves

gettyimages-2230523103.jpg


Two days after cutting Gunner Olszewski to make room for waiver claims Rico Payton and Beau Brade, the New York Giants have re-signed Olszewski to their 53-man roster.

To make room for Olszewski, the Giants are placing Payton on injured reserve.

Placing Payton on IR is a move the Giants knew they would have to make when they claimed him on waivers from the New Orleans Saints. Payton is a second-year cornerback/special teams player GM Joe Schoen said on Wednesday the team was hoping to acquire a year ago. They want to develop him, think he can help them on special teams, and seem likely to bring him to the 53-man roster whenever he is healthy.

Olszewski won a competition with Ihmir Smith-Marsette to be a backup wide receiver as well as the Giants’ primary punt and kickoff returner.

Olszewski played 10 games for the team in 2023 and spent last season on injured reserve. He returned to the Giants early in training camp after Bryce Ford-Wheaton suffered a torn Achilles during practice and was placed on injured reserve. The highlight of his 2023 season was a 94-yard punt return for a touchdown against the Los Angeles Rams.

Practice squad moves​


The Giants signed linebacker Zaire Barnes and offensive lineman McClendon Curtis to their practice squad, and terminated the contract of edge defender Trace Ford.

Cutting Ford, an undrafted free agent who was impressive during the summer, could be considered a surprise.

Barnes, 6-foot-1 and 227 pounds, was waived by the New York Jets on Wednesday. The Jets selected him out of Western Michigan in the sixth round of the 2023 NFL Draft. Barnes appeared in four games as a rookie but missed all of 2024 with an ankle injury.

Curtis, 6-6 and 330 pounds, was released by the Arizona Cardinals on Monday. Undrafted out of Chattanooga in 2023, Curtis began his career with the Las Vegas Raiders, where he played under current Giants offensive line coach Carmen Bricillo. Curtis also spent time with the Seattle Seahawks, playing in five games for Seattle over the past two seasons. All of his snaps were played on special teams.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...wski-returns-in-series-of-giants-roster-moves
 
Giants fans might not want to laugh too hard at the Micah Parsons trade

gettyimages-1315300616.jpg

Kadarius Toney is announced as the New York Giants’ Round One pick in the 2021 NFL Draft

Schadenfreude is one of the most appealing of human emotions. I can’t say I’m immune to it. Fans and writers of the Philadelphia Eagles and Washington Commanders are understandably gleeful over the Dallas Cowboys’ trade of Micah Parsons to Green Bay for two first round picks and defensive tackle Kenny Clark. Like the New York Giants, they won’t have to deal with Parsons twice every season, though all NFC East teams will see him once because they play Green Bay this year.

Giants fans, though, should be more circumspect about it than Eagles and Commanders fans. After all, four years ago the Giants were on the clock in the 2021 NFL Draft with Parsons still on the board at No. 11. He was there for the taking. Instead, then-GM Dave Gettleman traded down to No. 20. The haul of draft picks he got was considered admirable at the time, and as talented as Parsons obviously was, he played mostly off-ball linebacker in college, not considered a premium position, and there were character concerns as well.

Unfortunately, this is what the Giants got with those picks:

  • No. 20: Kadarius Toney
  • No. 164: Used in trade-up with Denver from No. 76 to No. 71 to draft Aaron Robinson
  • 2022 first-round pick (No. 7): Evan Neal
  • 2022 fourth-round pick (No. 112): Daniel Bellinger

Beyond that fiasco, the Giants have a pretty decent history of regrettable trades themselves. Here are a few:

1964: Sam Huff traded to Washington​

imagn-2157462.jpg

After three consecutive trips to the NFL Championship Game, the Giants traded future Hall of Fame linebacker Sam Huff to Washington for defensive back Dick James and defensive end Andy Stynchula. Huff had been reassured by Wellington Mara that he wouldn’t be traded. The Giants wound up going 2-10-2, the start of their 17-year “wilderness era” in which they made zero playoff appearances.

1972: Fran Tarkenton traded back to Minnesota​

gettyimages-78179516.jpg

When the Giants acquired Fran Tarkenton from Minnesota in 1967, it looked as if their wilderness era was going to be a short one. Tarkenton led them to consecutive 7-7 seasons, then 6-8, and then a 9-5 season in which they were eliminated from the playoffs on the last day of the season. After regressing to 4-10 in 1972, though, Tarkenton demanded a trade and was granted his wish. The Giants never did better than 6-10 until Phil Simms got them back to the playoffs in 1981, after Tarkenton’s replacement, Norm Snead, went 8-6 in 1972. Tarkenton took the Vikings to the Super Bowl in 1974, 1975, and 1977.

2018: Giants trade Jason Pierre-Paul to Tampa Bay

usa_today_9658568.jpg

One of the most fearsome pass rushers the Giants have ever had, Jason Pierre-Paul was traded by Gettleman to Tampa Bay after two-injury plagued seasons and a 2017 season which was good but less than several of his best. The Giants got a third-round pick that became defensive tackle B.J. Hill and a fourth-round pick swap that became quarterback Kyle Lauletta. Meanwhile, JPP returned to his early form and had three good seasons as a Buccaneer, including making the Pro Bowl in 2020. Hill was a good player with the Giants, so this wasn’t an awful outcome, but Gettleman later traded him for Billy Price, sealing the fate of the original trade and qualifying it for this list.

2019: Giants trade up for DeAndre Baker​

gettyimages-1178485393.jpg

In 2019, Gettleman traded up into the first round after having already taken Daniel Jones and Dexter Lawrence. With the No. 30 pick he obtained, he selected cornerback Deandre Baker. Baker was a disaster on the field, showing little ability to stay with good receivers and no ability to intercept passes. He also got into trouble off the field, although all charges against him were ultimately dropped. He was gone after a single season. The Giants gave Seattle the Nos. 37, 132, and 142 picks in order to move up. The move was well-intentioned, because the Giants desperately needed help at cornerback, and a run on cornerbacks was expected near the bottom of the first round and top of the second. That run did, in fact, materialize, and none of the cornerbacks taken just after Baker lived up to their draft promise. Some have at least been useful players, though: Byron Murphy, Rock-Ya Sin, Sean Murphy-Bunting.

In truth, it will be a while before we know who won the Micah Parsons trade. For now, Green Bay is likely to be the winner, because it automatically makes them a serious Super Bowl contender. Whether things actually work out that way remains to be seen. In the long run, it’s possible that Dallas has the last laugh. Kenny Clark appears to be on the downside of his career, but he had nine sacks and 61 total pressures as recently as 2023.

More importantly, the two first-round picks Dallas got could bring them two great players. In 2019, Giants fans were not happy that Gettleman traded Odell Beckham Jr. to Cleveland for Jabrill Peppers plus first- and third-round picks. The Giants were ridiculed for the trade, e.g., by Bill Barnwell of ESPN:

Something dramatic and inexplicable needs to have happened in those 13 days to make this trade make sense because it otherwise reads as if the Giants were hacked. Months after paying him a $20 million signing bonus, they traded one of the league’s best young players at any position to the Browns for the sort of offer the computer would reject in a video game.

This has the potential to be a franchise-resetting trade, the sort of deal that gets everyone fired and leaves fans muttering for decades about what could have been. The Giants have never had a player like OBJ before. Now, they don’t have him — or much of anything — at all.

We know how that ended. OBJ had one elite season as a Brown and has been compromised by injuries ever since, not playing a single full season and never even reaching 600 yards in any season. Meanwhile, the Giants drafted a guy named Dexter Lawrence with the first-round pick they got in the trade (Oshane Ximines was the other player they got).

The Giants may even have learned their lesson by holding onto the No. 3 pick this year and using it on Parsons’ successor at Penn State, Abdul Carter, who looked in training camp as if he might have a Parsons-sized impact in the NFL. On the other hand, Joe Schoen repeated Gettleman’s move of trading back into the first round this year to get Jaxson Dart. He’s hoping it works out less like the trade-up Gettleman made for Baker and more like the trade-up Baltimore made in 2018 to get Lamar Jackson at the end of the first round. For now, though, Giants fans may want to stifle their giggles, remembering the team’s own somewhat sordid history of big draft trades.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...-to-laugh-too-hard-at-the-micah-parsons-trade
 
Big Blue View mailbag: Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll, defining success for Giants, more

Mailbox-Logo.png


Jim asks: Going into the regular season everyone continues to tie the fate of GM Joe Schoen and HC Brian Daboll. My question is based on the quality of last years draft class and how this current draft class our GM seems to be doing his job pretty well. So if the team can’t win and it comes down to gameday execution that would land on Daboll not Schoen. Curious on your thoughts of uncoupling them based on how they are performing in their respective jobs.

Ed says: Jim, I know it might surprise some people but I really don’t think they are coupled at this point. Co-owner John Mara said a while ago that the GM and head coach have different jobs and can each be judged on their own.

If ownership thinks the talent on the roster is better than the results on the field I can see Schoen staying and Daboll going. I can see Schoen trying to support Daboll, but he isn’t going to lose his own job over whether Daboll stays or goes.



Larry Bassell asks: Given that our DC Shane Bowen has had a few months to prepare for Washington and that he has seen a lot of tape on Daniels, how do you think he adjusts how we defend him this year vs. last year. If I recall, we were competitive in both games.

Ed says: Larry, the Giants have not spent the last six or seven months preparing for the Washington Commanders. When we ask Brian Daboll things like this, he says “we’re focused on us.”

Now, it is probably true that some of the bottom-rung guys on the Giants coaching staff have been watching and cutting up film of every team on the Giants schedule for months. That doesn’t mean Daboll has watched much of it. Or that Bowen has been focused on it. They have been focused on getting their team ready.

On Monday, Daboll said “We’ll get to Washington here in the next few days.” He said on Wednesday that the Giants would do some “Washington stuff.”

All of that said, it will be interesting to see how the Giants employ Abdul Carter. Could he spend some time “spying” Daniels? How will they pressure him and try to keep him in the pocket?



Richard Girgenti asks: Long time reader! My question is more of an observation and wondering your opinion on it in regards to Jalin Hyatt. One thing I have noticed is every time he catches or attempts to catch a deep ball, he tends to do it while falling to the ground. That might be the way the ball is thrown, but I notice it more often than not, whereas other receivers attempt to catch the long ball in stride. Am I off on this? Is this an indication of something that should (and maybe is) being worked by coaches with him? Am I seeing this wrong or just incorrectly on this? Thoughts?

Ed says: Richard, I honestly don’t know if you are right or wrong on this. It’s not something that has ever jumped out or really occurred to me. What I will say is that even though he has gained weight, I think the contested catch remains on issue for Hyatt. Maybe that is some of what you are seeing.



Bob Donnelly asks: Is the OLine fixed? If so, is it a temporary repair or will it carry over into 2026?

Ed says: Bob, no one should EVER consider the offensive line fixed. Or, any position for that matter.

Brian Daboll always says a couple of things that apply here. First, he says the NFL is a week-to-week league. From one week to the next, you never know exactly what you are going to get. Who is healthy? Which teams are playing well? Which teams are desperate for a win? Which teams are cruising? Which teams are on short weeks or exhausted by travel.

Daboll also says that every year is a new year. What happened last year or what the roster looked like a year ago doesn’t mean anything.

It is the same when you look ahead. The 2025 season hasn’t started yet. We think the offensive line will be OK in 2025, but we don’t know that. We think a lot of things, but none of it has been proven or disproven.

There is no way to know if Jon Runyan, Jermaine Eluemunor or John Michael Schmitz will be Giants next year. We don’t know yet if Evan Neal can be a good guard, or if he will be a Giant next year. Are we 100% certain Marcus Mbow can handle a starting job at right tackle tackle? Do we know if Andrew Thomas can stay healthy, or if the All-Pro version of Thomas still exists?

Let’s not talk about 2026 until we know something about 2025.

John Urbielewicz asks: Hate to see Elijah Chatman get waived. I’ve been a fan ever since he ran down a ball carrier 40 yards down field last preseason. As an undersized interior defensive lineman, unable to anchor against the run, would not he be better served playing defensive end? I think he has the speed and ability to set the edge.

Ed says: John, I hated to see Chatman dropped from the 53-man roster, as well. I was glad that the Giants brought him back to the practice squad. Maybe we will see him later this season.

As far as defensive end, I think I would trust the judgment of defensive coordinator Shane Bowen and defensive line coach Andre Patterson, one of the most success defensive line coaches in the business, on where to play him. I am not a scout, but I would think his height and length would be an issue trying to bend the edge against offensive tackles who are 6-foot-5 or so and 315-320 pounds. Guards, who may not be as athletic as tackles, seem like his best matchup. It’s just those double teams and all that traffic inside that cause him an issue.



Ken Diamond asks: Where do you think Jaxson Dart would be drafted if, somehow, there was a re-draft now, after the preseason?

Ed says: In that alternate reality, I do wonder if the Cleveland Browns (DT Mason Graham at No. 5) or New York Jets (OL Armand Membou at No. 7) would take Dart.

I have to believe the New Orleans Saints (OL Kelvin Banks at No. 9) would love a do-over. They are starting Spencer Rattler over Tyler Shough, an admission that Shough may never be an NFL starting quarterback after seven years in college, and that can’t be how they wanted to begin Kelvin Moore’s tenure as their head coach.

By not taking Dart at No. 9 when they had the chance, and I know it would have been considered a reach at the time, they are basically throwing away a year.



Phulmattie Budhram asks: Tough schedule aside, what might be the biggest roadblock in your opinion preventing this Giants team from being possible contender this season? What would you consider to be a “successful Giants football season”?

Ed says: Phulmattie, the schedule is the biggest roadblock. I hate to put numbers to what would be a successful season, but let’s do this.

Getting to the playoffs, or at least being in the hunt for a playoff spot, would absolutely be a successful season after going 3-14 in 2024. That said, I think you could also call it a successful season if the Giants win six or seven games — double what they won a year ago — get a few starts from Jaxson Dart, and come out of the year convinced he is their guy going forward.



Jim Kadamus asks: I’ve read injury statistics from the NFL that 68% of players get injured in any given season. And 30-50% are injured enough to miss games.

Thinking about the frequency of injuries, has the NFL and players union considered raising the roster limit by 10% from 53 to 58 and then having a 12 man practice squad?

Maybe then the gyrations for players going from roster to practice squad and back on roster (for example the Olszewski vs. Smith-Marsette situation) could be minimized.


Ed says: Jim, I don’t think that is in the cards. Maybe a roster expansion could be negotiated in the next Collective Bargaining Agreement, especially if ownership demands an 18-game schedule. I don’t see it happening now, though.

Practice squads have been expanded to 16 players, and veteran players can now be included. IR rules have been loosened so that not all players who are placed on IR before Week 1 have to miss the entire season, and players who go on IR during the season can be designated to return. Two practice squad players can be elevated to the active roster each week.

There will always be roster gyrations. There will also be some type of limit, and some type of cap.

If I was NFL Commissioner for a day, the thing I would like to change is the 46-man game day roster. You have 53 players, so let 53 players be active on game day. If you have five guys injured who can’t play, elevate five guys from your practice squad and then be allowed to return them without having to pass them through waivers.



John Kozel asks: Can you provide any details you know about the swapping of Korie Black for Rico Payton? If you claim a guy that causes you to make a player available you say you like and then put the new player on the injured list, it looks to me like a bad miscalculation. I’m assuming there is more and it’s not a gross mistake. Any insight?

Ed says: John, when teams set their “initial” 53-man rosters on cutdown day they know there will be changes. They kept seven cornerbacks, which is probably more than they actually wanted to go into Week 1 against the Commanders with. They did that because they liked Korie Black, as well as Art Green and Nic Jones, and hoped to keep them all.

I have said several times they claimed Rico Payton because he is a player they have coveted since last preseason. They knew he was injured and would need a couple of weeks. He has what I have seen reported as a back injury that will take a couple of weeks to heal. He will be eligible to return from IR after four games.

They believed Black would clear waivers, which he did, and then would re-sign to their practice squad. The Jets made Black an offer to join their practice squad and he accepted it. That qualifies as a surprise, but it is the player’s right.

As far as I know, the Ravens wanted Beau Brade to return to their practice squad and the Saints wanted Payton on their practice squad. The Giants didn’t let those things happen because they wanted those players.

I don’t see it as a miscalculation. Other teams have scouts, too. The Giants also hoped tight end Greg Dulcich would return to their practice squad, but he felt the opportunity was better for him with the Miami Dolphins.

Brian Misdom asks: What do you make of the giants decision to keep Gunner Olszewski over Ihmir Smith-Marsette? Is the upside at WR really that much of a differentiating factor when a slew of injuries would be needed to receive meaningful snaps?

I didn’t mind Gunner in 2023 but Ihmir proved a useful return player in 2024 without the fumbling issue that has plagued Gunner.

On pure return duties, thought Ihmir had the edge.


Ed says: Brian, this choice surprised me a little bit. I think the Giants saw the return job as a wash between the two, though my $.02 is that Smith-Marsette would be better on kickoffs. Based on what we saw in the summer, Olszewski is well ahead of Smith-Marsette as a receiver, and that might have been the deciding factor.


Submit a question​


Have a Giants-related question? E-mail it to [email protected] and it might be featured in our weekly mailbag.

Source: https://www.bigblueview.com/new-yor...brian-daboll-defining-success-for-giants-more
 
Back
Top