Photo by George Gojkovich/Getty Images
It has been 20 years since the Miami Dolphins traded star cornerback Patrick Surtain to the Kansas City Chiefs. It is time to take a look back.
Somehow, 20 years have passed since cornerback Patrick Surtain was traded by the
Miami Dolphins to the
Kansas City Chiefs. It has been such a long time that Surtain’s son, Patrick Surtain II, is now a star cornerback for the
Denver Broncos. It is not possible that this much time has already passed, but apparently it is true.
The Dolphins selected Surtain in the second round of the 1998
NFL Draft, pairing him with 1997 second-round pick Sam Madison to create a dominating duo that was seen as one of the best cornerback tandems in the league.
Surtain spent seven years with Miami, appearing in 108 games with 82 starts and recording 353 tackles, 77 passes defensed, 29 interceptions with two touchdowns, four forced fumbles, five fumble recoveries, and 6.5 sacks. He was named to the
Pro Bowl in 2002, 2003, and 2004 and was a First-Team All-Pro selection in 2002 and a Second-Team selection in 2003.
After the 2004 season, however, the Dolphins and Surtain could not reach an agreement on a new contract and Miami allowed Surtain to look for a trade. In April, Miami and Kansas City agreed to a deal, and the duo of Madison and Surtain ended.
Twenty years later, what does that trade look like? We take a look back at the deal.
Dolphins-Chiefs trade recap:
Dolphins receive:
2005 second-round pick
2005 fifth-round pick
Chiefs receive:
Patrick Surtain, cornerback
2005 fifth-round pick
What happened with the picks?
- Dolphins’ 2005 second-round pick (46th overall): Matt Roth, defensive end, Iowa
- Chiefs’ 2005 fifth-round pick (138th overall): Boomer Grigsby, linebacker, Illinois State
- Dolphins 2005 fifth-round pick (162nd overall): Anthony Alabi, tackle, TCU
Recapping the players’ careers:
Dolphins:
Roth started his career as a rotational player behind Jason Taylor and Kevin Carter, moving into the starting lineup in his third season. He moved back into a linebacker role in 2008 as the Dolphins transitioned from a 4-3 front into a 3-4, continuing to serve as a starter as an edge rusher. In 2009, Roth failed the team’s conditioning test at the start of training camp; then head coach Tony Sparano indicated Roth had an illness, while Drew Rosenhaus, Roth’s agent, reported the issue as a groin injury. Roth was placed on the non-football injury list to start the season, eventually appearing in four games before Miami waived him. The
Cleveland Browns claimed him off waivers, playing six games at the end of the season there, then returning as their starting outside linebacker in 2010. In 2011, Roth spent one season with the
Jacksonville Jaguars. With Miami, Roth played in 65 games (23 starts), with 157 tackles, five passes defensed, six forced fumbles, two fumble recoveries, and 12.5 sacks.
Alabi was inactive each week throughout his rookie season. He appeared in six games in 2006, then in 10 games in 2007. Miami waived him after the 2007 season, with the Chiefs claiming him off waivers, but waiving him at the end of the 2008 preseason. He signed with the
Tampa Bay Buccaneers after the 2008 season, but was waived at the start of the 2009 season. Since leaving football, Alabi has transitioned into acting.
Chiefs:
Surtain joined the Chiefs coming off three-straight Pro Bowl appearances. He immediately assumed a role as a starting cornerback, spending three seasons there before sliding back into a reserve role, in part because of a shoulder issue, in 2008. He was released after the 2008 season, leading to his retirement. With Kansas City, Surtain appeared in 55 games, starting 49 of them, with 194 tackles, 28 passes defensed, eight interceptions, four forced fumbles, three fumble recoveries, and one sack.
Grigbsy appeared in all 16 games as a rookie, playing as a reserve linebacker and a special teams player. He continued in that role through the 2006 season, then transitioned to playing fullback in 2007. The Chiefs declined a to tender Grigsby as a restricted free agent after the season and he signed a one-year contract with the Dolphins, assuming the starting fullback position but he only lasted two games before the Dolphins made a move to sign a free agent fullback. After sitting out the rest of the 2008 season, Grigsby attempted to return to football with the
Houston Texans, but an injury sidelined him during training camp and he was released at the end of the preseason.
Who won the trade?
Maybe the Dolphins won this trade because Surtain could not match the peak of his playing days in Miami with the Chiefs, but this also signaled the end of a defensive era in Miami. Starting in 2005, the Dolphins were 9-7, then were 6-10, and 1-15 before the 11-5 2008 season. Other than that one year, when
New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady was injured and the Dolphins found a spark with Comeback Player of the Year quarterback Chad Pennington, Miami did not make a playoff appearance until 2016. Surtain’s trade was not what caused a generation of struggles in Miami, but it was an early part of the process leading to the tough time Miami is still trying to end.
Surtain was good for the Chiefs, if not the All-Pro, Pro Bowl player Miami had when he was paired with Madison.
Roth was a solid player for a few years for the Dolphins. Alabi and Grigsby were players, but nothing remarkable about either of their careers.