Los Angeles Dodgers
Hall of Famer
2025 Dodgers season review: Ben Rortvedt
Source: https://www.truebluela.com/los-angeles-dodgers-news-notes/107621/ben-rortvedt-2025-dodgers-review
![]()
One does not expect a backup catcher to become beloved by a fanbase. One especially does not expect the backup’s backup to become beloved to a fanbase, in record time no less, and then displace the backup catcher in terms of depth on the playoff roster.
Dalton Rushing had pedigree. Ben Rortvedt had none and was seemingly destined to be the answer to the trivia question of who was the third-string catcher on the Dodgers.
Rortvedt’s defense and pitch calling have generally been major league-ready. Why Rortvedt has been predominantly a backup catcher is his bat. His best offensive year was in 2024 when he essentially became the Rays’ primary catcher, playing in 112 games.
Rortvedt started the year with the Rays as the Rays’ backup catcher for the first two months, playing in 26 games. He put offensive stats that were truly offensive and would have made Austin Barnes’ limited offensive production in 2025 seem like an upgrade. Rortvedt had a slash line of .095/.186/.111 (6 for 63) with one double and six runs batted in.
The Tampa Bay Rays have added C Matt Thaiss to the active roster and designated C Ben Rortvedt for assignment.
— Rays Communications (@rayspr.bsky.social) 2025-05-28T13:31:47.026Z
On June 1, the Rays outrighted Rortvedt to play for the Triple-A Durham Bulls (yes, again, THOSE ones, even though it was a single-A team in the movie). While at Durham, Rortvedt assumed the role of reserve catcher and did post marginal improvements in offense. In 19 games, Rortvedt had a slash line of .183/.315/.283. Hitting a homer off Rich “Dick Mountain” Hill will do that.
BYE BYE BASEBALL
Ben Rortvedt crushes a 3-run homer off Rich Hill to give us a 5-0 lead in the 4th! pic.twitter.com/sWAtl2PRk8
— Durham Bulls (@DurhamBulls) June 21, 2025
The Dodgers did not do much at the Trade Deadline. While they did trade Dustin May, they also traded Hunter Feduccia in a three-team deal that also netted Rortvedt, Paul Gervase, and Adam Serwinowski.
No one expected Rortvedt to do anything; he was just filling a depth role that did not require a 40-man roster slot, unlike the now-departed Hunter Feduccia. While with Triple-A Oklahoma City, Rortvedt played in 17 games and was modestly successful at the plate, hitting .228/.281/.386 with two home runs (in the same game) and six RBIs.
Ben Rortvedt does it again!!!
This ball left the yard QUICK!pic.twitter.com/0K4O9j530B
— Oklahoma City Comets (@OKC_comets) August 9, 2025
During an utterly disastrous road trip to Pittsburgh on September 3rd, Will Smith broke his hand off a fluke deflection of a foul ball. While the Dodgers figured out that Smith’s hand was actually broken with a hairline fracture, Rortvedt was called up to provide coverage, with Dalton Rushing assuming the starter’s role.
By a combination of a lack of good baseball in Pittsburgh and sheer bad luck, Rortvedt made his Dodger debut with the game on the line in the finale of the Pittsburgh series. He whiffed badly.
Rortvedt became the de facto starting catcher 24 hours later in Baltimore, when Dalton Rushing suffered a bone bruise directly in front of me. What did Rortvedt do on his first day as the starting catcher the next day? Call a game where Yoshinobu Yamamoto was one out away from throwing what would have been the only no-hitter in baseball in 2025.
Yes, the Dodgers ended up somehow losing that game in comedic fashion, but Rortvedt’s catching bona fides instantly captured the imagination of the fanbase. The Legend of Benny Biceps was born.
Where 2024 had Brent Honeywell, Ben Rortvedt clearly filled this same fan-favorite role. Rortvedt easily had one of the most memeable walk-up songs in recent memory. The fact that Rortvedt is, to put it politely, jacked while also wearing tight clothes made him a dark-horse favorite for the fanbase.
View Link
Rortvedt was adequate at the plate, but he did not need to be anything else.
There was a direct correlation between the Dodgers’ starting pitcher renaissance in September and Rortvedt becoming the de facto starting catcher. Two days after Yamamoto’s no-hitter bid was sundered, Tyler Glasnow had seven no-hit innings, which the bullpen also fumbled in the ninth inning. Rortvedt did the difficult job of coming to a new team and handling the staff with aplomb.
“That’s really, really hard,” Dodgers bench coach Danny Lehmann said. “But his personality and the way he goes about things shows that he cares. It’s evident in his work and his meetings and talking to the guys, and putting defense first when he’s supposed to.”
His teammates liked him. The staff liked him. The fans liked him, even in the rare moments when he goofed.
View Link
Smith missed the rest of the regular season due to his injury, and once Rushing returned from the injured list, no one was clamoring for Rushing to return behind the plate. A new sheriff was minding the store and handling the Dodgers’ rotation like an old pro.
Once the playoffs started, while Smith was on the roster, he was not ready to return to active, full-time duty. Therefore, Rortvedt caught every inning of the Wild Card round and continued his effective play. With the start of the Division Series against the Phillies, for the first two games, Rortvedt caught the first half of the game before Smith came into the game to finish.
After this point, while Rortvedt was on the roster for the remainder of the postseason run, he did not play another inning. This decision not to play Rortvedt proved a tad problematic after the marathon epic of Game 3 of the World Series.
If there was a moment to revisit the 2024 punting strategy, it was probably Game 4 of the World Series. Instead, role players like Alex Call, Rortvedt, and Hyeseong Kim sat, and the aging Dodgers core shuffled their way through two lifeless efforts before heading back to Toronto. It all eventually worked out, but the margin for comfort was far narrower than it needed to be.
Just like how the Honeywell saga suddenly ended last year, there would be no second season with Rortvedt in Los Angeles. The Dodgers avoided arbitration with Rortvedt by signing him to a $1.25 million/1-year deal, and then put him on waivers with the hope that he would both go unclaimed and that Rortvedt would accept the original assignment as a non-roster depth piece.
On November 12, the Cincinnati Reds thwarted the Dodgers’ plan by claiming Rortvedt.
C Ben Rortvedt signed a $1.25 million big league deal with the Dodgers before being put on waivers, per source. He was arbitration eligible.
Rortvedt was claimed off waivers yesterday by the Reds.
— Kiley McDaniel (@kileymcd) November 13, 2025
Upon being claimed, Rortvedt took the time to thank Dodgers fans for their support during his all-too-brief tenure.
It was tough when I came in but I really appreciate the support. It’s been really cool to come in and try to do my job but feel support from the fans and be able to be myself.
A combination of circumstances and opportunity allowed Ben Rortvedt to show what he can truly do at the Major League level in 2025. Regardless of what he does next, Dodgers fans will likely always remember the wildly successful stint this backup to the backup who became the primary backstop for six weeks had on the successful quest for a title defense.
2025 particulars
Age: 28
Stats: (with LA) .224/.309/.327/.636, 18 G, HR, 4 RBI, 2 2B, 7 R, 4 BB, 9 K, 83 wRC+, .1 rWAR, .2 fWAR
Salary: $1.125 million (of which the Dodgers were responsible for a prorated minimum)
Game of the year
Technically, one could say pick a day where Rortvedt caught in September as his game of the year, considering the tear the rotation went on to close out the regular season campaign. As the rules of this segment require me to pick a singular game, I will pick Rortvedt’s most productive offensive day at the plate while wearing a Dodger uniform: Game 2 of the Wild Card series, where he went for two for three with a double and scored two runs.
Roster status
Rortvedt is now on the Reds’ 40-man roster. Godspeed, Benny Biceps.
Source: https://www.truebluela.com/los-angeles-dodgers-news-notes/107621/ben-rortvedt-2025-dodgers-review