The trade deadline has come and gone. While trade season was slow to get started this year, when all was said and done, there were several dozen trades made in a flurry of movement over the final few days before the deadline arrived. The full impact of these trades won’t be known for years to come, but that doesn’t mean we can’t analyze the deals and decide whose haul looks the best right now. Over the next week-plus, MLBTR will be running a series of polls asking which club in each division had the best deadline. Yesterday, the Phillies came out on top in the NL East with
about half the vote. Today, we’ll be taking a look at the NL Central. A look at each of the five clubs, listed from best to worst record in 2025:
Milwaukee Brewers
The Brewers have the best record in baseball but had a fairly quiet deadline. Perhaps their most impactful move of the summer came last month, when they traded away
Aaron Civale to land former top prospect
Andrew Vaughn from the White Sox. Vaughn had struggled in Chicago for years but has caught fire with the Brewers and has proven to be an anchor for a lineup that’s without
Rhys Hoskins and
Jackson Chourio. Looking at deals made closer to the deadline, Milwaukee swapped out another big league starter to add a hitter when they shipped
Nestor Cortes to the Padres alongside infield prospect
Jorge Quintana and cash in order to bring in outfielder
Brandon Lockridge.
Another unusual trade for Milwaukee was acquiring injured closer
Shelby Miller and injured lefty
Jordan Montgomery in exchange for a player to be named later or cash. Montgomery won’t pitch this year, so the deal essentially saw the Brewers buy Miller off of the Diamondbacks in exchange for eating some of Montgomery’s salary. Perhaps the only typical buy-side addition was catcher
Danny Jansen, who they acquired from the Rays to back up
William Contreras. Dealing away Cortes and Civale hasn’t seemed to hurt the team much, but their additions are fairly modest on paper.
Chicago Cubs
The Cubs have fallen behind the Brewers after posting a somewhat pedestrian 29-25 record since the start of June, and entered trade season in clear need of upgrades. Perhaps their most impactful addition was utility man
Willi Castro, a switch-hitter who can help take pressure off of rookie
Matt Shaw at third base while upgrading the bench to make giving regulars like
Dansby Swanson and
Ian Happ days off more feasible. Deals with the Orioles and Pirates to acquire veteran setup man
Andrew Kittredge and southpaw
Taylor Rogers should help bolster a bullpen that had been relying on reclamation projects like
Brad Keller and
Drew Pomeranz to this point, as well.
Despite those generally solid additions, the Cubs did not substantially address their biggest need this summer: starting pitching. It was no secret that adding rotation help was a top priority for Chicago with
Justin Steele done for the year,
Jameson Taillon and
Javier Assad both on the injured list, and both
Cade Horton and
Matthew Boyd in uncharted territory in terms of innings. Unfortunately for the Cubs, they were unable to find much help in that regard on the market.
Michael Soroka was added in a trade with the Nationals in order to pitch in, but his velocity was down in his last few outings with the Nats and now he’s
headed for the injured list with shoulder discomfort. While the club’s bench and bullpen additions were solid, it’s unclear if that will be enough to outweigh the lack of impactful rotation help down the stretch.
Cincinnati Reds
The 59-54 Reds currently sit just three games out of a Wild Card spot in the NL, and that was enough to convince them to go for it this summer. They made three trades to round out their roster. They picked up right-hander
Zack Littell from the Rays in a three-team deal that sent righty
Brian Van Belle to Tampa and lefty
Adam Serwinowski to the Dodgers. They added
Miguel Andujar to their bench in a deal with the A’s and, most interestingly, they picked up third baseman
Ke’Bryan Hayes from the Pirates in exchange for Rogers (who was later traded to the Cubs) and shortstop prospect
Sammy Stafura.
Littell should provide some depth for an already-strong rotation that has a history of struggling to stay healthy (as was reinforced by
Nick Lodolo’s departure from yesterday’s game after just 1 2/3 innings of work). Andujar provides a lefty-mashing bench bat to a club that has struggled badly against southpaws this year, but Hayes is the most interesting addition of the bunch. A former top prospect and Gold Glove award winner at third base, Hayes is one of the most talented defenders in the sport but hit just .236/.279/.290 (57 wRC+) in 100 games with the Pirates this year and has a career wRC+ of just 84. His relatively pricey contract makes bringing him in a gamble, but if he can float a slash line even close to league average, he should be a 3-win player when healthy.
St. Louis Cardinals
The Cardinals sold at the deadline for the second time in three years, but in doing so they only traded veterans on expiring contracts. Right-hander
Erick Fedde was the first domino to fall, as the veteran starter was shipped to the Braves for a player to be named later or cash amid a disappointing season that saw him designated for assignment just before the deal. Veteran setup man
Phil Maton netted a pair of prospects from the Rangers, one of whom is now St. Louis’s #26 ranked prospect at
MLB Pipeline, and swingman
Steven Matz was shipped to the Red Sox in a deal that brought back power-hitting first baseman
Blaze Jordan (
#18 in the Cardinals’ system, per Pipeline).
The team’s biggest deal this summer, however, was shipping out closer
Ryan Helsley to the Mets. Even in the midst of a down season by his standards, Helsley brought back a trio of talented players: infield prospect
Jesus Baez (
#6 in the Cardinals’ system, per Pipeline), righty pitching prospect
Nate Dohm (
#15), and right-handed prospect
Frank Elissalt (unranked). It’s a solid group of talent to bring in for a handful of rentals on expiring deals and the moves should help set incoming president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom up for success as John Mozeliak departs the club at the end of the season.
Pittsburgh Pirates
The Pirates also sold off pieces this summer, although their deadline was quiet for a club that entered July with
Paul Skenes and
Andrew McCutchen as their only two
untouchable players. Not only did widely-speculated trade candidate
Mitch Keller stay put despite a market starved for controllable rotation talent, but a number of rental players for whom the Pirates have little use did not end up getting cashed in for prospects and/or salary relief.
Isiah Kiner-Falefa,
Tommy Pham,
Andrew Heaney, and
Tim Mayza all remain in town. And some deals they did make, such as the
David Bednar swap with the Yankees, produced underwhelming returns.
That’s not to say everything about the club’s deadline was disappointing, however. The Pirates did manage to get out from under the Hayes contract, and then flipped Rogers to get an additional prospect from the Cubs. Lefty
Caleb Ferguson and infielder
Adam Frazier both were successfully cashed in for prospect talent and the Bucs received a return led by intriguing MLB-ready reliever
Evan Sisk when they looked to sell on back-end starter
Bailey Falter. Some of those young players acquired should help the Pirates going forward, and getting Hayes off the books should make adding offense easier for 2026 and beyond. Even so, it’s fair to wonder if this deadline represents a missed opportunity in Pittsburgh.
The NL Central was one of the quieter divisions in baseball this deadline, with only a handful of non-rental players changing hands and no blockbusters. With that being said, three teams did make an effort to get better for 2025, while the Cardinals and Pirates picked up a number of pieces for their futures. Which club did the best of this quintet? Have your say in the poll below:
Take Our Poll