Photo by Brandon Sloter/Getty Images
Day 1 of the free agency period for Cleveland only had one development
Cleveland Browns GM Andrew Berry has always begun NFL free agency period with a “splash” signing or two.
Not that these signings amounted to much, but at the time they seemed grand: OT Jack Conklin in 2020, CB Troy Hill in 2021, 2022’s DT Taven Bryan, S Juan Thornhill for 2023, and LB Jordan Hicks last year.
Some hits, and some misses.
RELATED: KENNY PICKETT - GRADING THE TRADE
So, it was a very unusual first day of free agency for the Browns 2025 edition. No splashes, no rumors, and no excitement of what is next or an unexpected player signed right at noon.
Browns fans can decide how they feel about the one move that was made:
Trade: Eagles are trading QB Kenny Pickett to the Cleveland Browns for a 2025 fifth-round pick and QB Dorian Thompson-Robinson, per sources.
pic.twitter.com/U6ZagO62Rq
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter)
March 10, 2025
However, there was a trade. The Browns are getting QB Kenny Pickett in exchange for QB Dorian Thompson-Robinson (DTR) and a 2025 fifth-round draft pick. No, really.
The Browns starting QB, Deshaun Watson, appears his injury to his Achilles heel will not heal before the season opener. It has been rumored that Watson may not play at all in 2025. So, DTR was the only quarterback on the roster. Now that he is gone, Pickett is the only quarterback on the roster.
Which seems strange since Cleveland set an NFL record for most starting quarterbacks in consecutive seasons with nine. Now, they are technically down to one healthy signalcaller.
On the surface, this trade appears to be one developmental QB disappointment for another developmental QB disappointment.
The trade
What is behind the trade?
For one, the Browns went into Day 1 of the free agency period without a starting quarterback. Or a backup quarterback.
Which one will Pickett fill? The answer is: we will see.
Pickett (6’-3”, 220 pounds) came into the NFL from the University of Pittsburgh, where he was a finalist for every quarterback achievement award: Heisman Trophy, Maxwell Award, Walter Camp Award, Davey O’Brien National Quarterback Award, and Manning Award. He did win the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award and the Panther Award.
Photo by Bryan Bedder/Getty Images
As a senior, Pickett was the ACC Player of the Year, voted First Team All-ACC, and named First Team All-American.
In his senior season, he threw 42 touchdown passes. No, not a misprint. His completion ratio was an outstanding 67.2% and he tossed just seven interceptions. At the conclusion of his college career, Pickett had played in 52 games, had 1,045 completions on 1,674 attempts for 12,303 yards, 81 TD passes, 32 picks, a 62.4% completion ratio, and a 136.3 QB rating. He also rushed for 800 yards on 418 attempts with an additional 21 touchdowns.
He finished his career as Pitt’s all-time leader in passing yards (12,303), pass completions (1,045), total offense (13,112), touchdown responsibility (102), and passing touchdowns (81). That’s a very good pedigree. But tearing up college defenses is a long way from being able to read an NFL defensive scheme.
The Pittsburgh Steelers took him with the 20th pick in the first round of the 2022 NFL draft. This is where the fairytale ends.
Photo by Joe Sargent/Getty Images
In his first game of his rookie season in Week 4 when the Steelers benched started Mitchell Trubisky, Picket threw three interceptions. Before the season concluded, he had two concussions, seven TDs, and nine interceptions. In his second season, he had a bone bruise and a high ankle sprain and finished his season with the lowest touchdown percentage of all eligible starting quarterbacks.
Pickett did provide six fourth-quarter comebacks and seven game-winning drives during his time with the Steelers.
During the 2024 off-season, Pittsburgh signed free agent Russell Wilson, and Pickett requested a trade. Before those words were completely out of his mouth, the Steelers shipped him to the Eagles along with a fourth-round pick for a third-round pick, two seventh-round picks, a bag of footballs, and a stack of Chick-Fil-A coupons. Or something like that.
The Steelers did their due diligence by sending Pickett out of the conference.
Pickett then became Jalen Hurts’ backup. It wasn’t like Pickett had a year behind some master quarterback with a ton of experience and Super Bowl victories (yet), either. Yes, Hurts was getting better each season, but he is just two years older than Pickett. It wasn’t Patrick Mahomes, or Aaron Rodgers, or some other QB wonder to learn from.
Photo by Focus on Sport/Getty Images
However, Pickett was thrown into the QB room headed by QB coach Doug Nussmeier, who has been an offensive coach for 24 years and has won a college football national championship, a Grey Cup, and now a Super Bowl. And that is where Pickett spent his 2024 season, getting tutelage on how to become a starting quarterback in this league.
Being on the Eagles became a huge benefit as Philly won this year’s Super Bowl. Pickett had the final plays on the field for both the NFC Championship Game plus the Super Bowl.
DTR proved he was nothing more than a project and demonstrated why he was drafted in the fifth round. Pickett is a pretty good leap up from DTR - that much is certain.
How does the trade affect the Browns?
For one, Pickett could start. He has played in 30 NFL games with 25 starts. He took control of the Eagles in Week 16 after Hurts came out with a concussion as they were beaten by the Washington Commanders 36-33. The following week, he started and guided the team to a 34-6 spanking of division foe Dallas Cowboys.
Was Pickett chosen to be the Browns’ starting quarterback in 2025?
At the very least, he would be good insurance as the backup. In his three years as a pro, his completion ratio is still pretty good at 62.4%. But just like Jameis Winston, he just throws to the wrong team too many times with 14 picks total against 15 touchdowns.
He is a good game manager, but he isn’t going to light it up every game with 400 passing yards and 30+ points scored per game. Pickett needs a good running game behind him and a solid offensive line in front of him to give him the time to go through progressions.
Berry will need to fix Cleveland’s offensive line. Now. This year. The running back situation remains unsolved, so that is an issue as well.
Most likely, Berry will draft a young quarterback in this year’s draft. Will he start? Depends. Depends on who he selects and which round that player is taken.
Russell Wilson was a third-round draft pick and beat out the Number 1 free agent quarterback they signed that year to be their starter. So, anything is possible.
Photo by Dustin Markland/Getty Images
Jaxson Dart #2 of Ole Miss
If a guy like Jaxson Dart of Ole Miss is taken in the second round, most likely, it will be a competition between Pickett and Dart for the starting nod. If a third/fourth-round guy such as Will Howard of
Ohio State, Notre Dame’s Riley Leonard, or Kurtis Rourke of Indiana is taken, the depth chart will most likely become:
- QB1: Kenny Pickett
- QB2: This year’s draft pick
- QB3: free agent signing
- PS QB: undetermined
RELATED: JAXSON DART INTERVIEW
If the Browns use the #2 overall pick in the first round on a quarterback, then this will be the depth chart:
- QB1: Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders
- QB2: Kenny Pickett
- QB3: This year’s low-round draft pick or free agent
- PS QB: undetermined
For the Steelers, Pickett is not only back in the conference but has also returned to the division. Oops.
There is a possibility that Berry has not gotten the only quarterback he is targeting in free agency. Maybe Berry has focused on his backup QB and taken a flyer on a former first-round guy for next to nothing. Berry could sign another, which would provide a proven starter, thus placing Pickett at backup once again and the young draft pick as the developmental QB3.
Aaron Rodgers hasn’t been signed, although he hasn’t been rumored to the Browns. Then again, neither was Pickett. Joe Flacco is a fan fav. The Atlanta Falcons might still
be willing to get rid of Kirk Cousins. Russell Wilson is available. Daniel Jones is now with the Indianapolis Colts. Case Keenum, Drew Lock, Cooper Rush, Carson Wentz, and Trey Lance are still out there. Jacoby Brissett tied to Arizona.
Bill Streicher-Imagn Images
Pickett is in the final year of his rookie deal, which will pay him $2.6 million. His fifth-year option will need to be addressed at some point. He is just 26 years old and can continue to grow into a starting QB in this league. With the Browns, he does perhaps get a shot to start again, which he would never do with Philadelphia who love Hurts as their starter, plus the development of backup QB Tanner McKee.
Before free agency began, the Browns’ quarterback room had more questions than answers. Now, suddenly, there is some clarity.
The backup quarterback role is solved.