The Minnesota Twins have missed the playoffs for the fourth time in the last five seasons after their latest and greatest collapse. The good news is that there is still plenty of baseball to watch for the next month featuring some of the best players in recent Twins history.
With 12 teams in the postseason, we need some clear criteria on how to break them down. So with that in mind, we’ll be using the following five categories and assigning a score between 1-10 for each. Best cumulative score wins all Twins fans’ support for October.
- Twins Connections: how connected are you to the Minnesota Twins? This includes former Twins players, prospects, coaches, or greater Minnesota ties. Additionally, are there any current Twins who would get rings if you win the World Series? The longer tenured your former Twins, the better your score.
- Entertainment: How fun is it to watch you play baseball? Style of play is a factor, but moreso do you have players and storylines that are fun to root for and players who have fun on the field? Think Harrison Bader. Ironically, a bad bullpen also plays up here because it keeps things interesting.
- Ethical Ball: This is the style-of-play and anti-Cleveland Guardians category, who I find both infuriating and unenjoyable to watch. We don’t want all homers or all dink-and-dunk singles, we want a power/speed mix, aces to carry you, and an elite bullpen with good stuff.
- Most Recent World Series: This is straightforward, how recently have you won a championship? I like some 2019 Nationals/2023 Diamondbacks out-of-nowhere deep postseason runs, sorry Dodgers.
- Intangibles: a catch-all category to award or dock points as I see fit. Is your owner ideologically aligned with the Pohlads? How many former Cleveland Guardians do you have on your roster? Do you now or have you ever employed Aroldis Chapman? Are you the Yankees? All these things will lower your score in the intangibles category.
We’ll go by postseason seeding and award a champion at the end. Let’s get into the definitive guide of who Twins fans should root for this postseason!
Toronto Blue Jays
Twins Connections: 7/10
- Jose Berrios: 6 seasons with Twins
- Louis Varland: 4 seasons with Twins
- David Popkins (coach): 3 seasons as Twins hitting coach
- Ty France/Isiah Kiner-Falefa 1 season(ish) with Twins
- Jeff Hoffman: Spring Training with Twins that revitalized his career
- Twins Rings: Alan Roden
Berrios was one of my favorite Twins while he was here and Varland was a great development success story and a Minnesota native to boot. There’s also something funny about the Twins firing Popkins, him going to the Jays and Toronto immediately having the best offense in MLB. And while it would be fun for Roden to get a ring, his 12 games with the Twins before his injury were uninspiring and I have no personal connection to him.
Entertainment: 7/10
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is as fun as they come and had an excellent season after a rough start. George Springer has revived his career and put up a 166 wRC+ (career best) and 5.2 WAR (second highest of career) at 35 years old. Alejandro Kirk is like if Willians Astudillo was actually good. After that, every single player in their regular lineup has an above-average wRC+ except for Andres Gimenez, who is one of the five best fielders in baseball. Bo Bichette may be able to return to DH in the ALDS as well, bringing another strong bat to a deep lineup.
On the pitching side, things are a bit more suspect, which could actually make things more entertaining. Injuries to Jose Berrios and Chris Bassitt leave questions in the rotation after ace Twins 2023 postseason legend Kevin Gausman. Shane Bieber, who just returned from Tommy John surgery, is lined up to start Game 2 of the ALDS, while 42-year-old Max Scherzer and 2024 draftee Trey Yesavage (80-grade name) are in line to start games 3 and 4, respectively. A questionable bullpen leaves just enough entertainment late in the game.
Ethical Ball: 6/10
While the pitching woes will make for some strong entertainment, the Jays lose some points here for their lack of starting pitching and questionable bullpen. Conversely, their lineup ranks high here. They have a strong mix of power bats (Springer, Vladdy, Addison Barger) and elite role players that do the small things well (Nathan Lukes, Daulton Varsho, Ernie Clement, Gimenez). If Anthony Santander can shake off injury-related slump and Bichette can return, the lineup is good enough for me to bump their score to a 7.
Recent World Series: 8/10
The Blue Jays haven’t won a championship or league pennant since 1993, though this is relatively recent compared to other postseason teams, which knocks them down to an 8.
Intangibles: 9/10
Thankfully, this team has never employed Aroldis Chapman, is not the Yankees, and the ownership consortium does not seem to align themselves with the Pohlads’ way of thinking. Rogers Communication, the Canadian telecom company that owns the Jays, has repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to invest on the field and their community. They were one of the finalists for Shohei Ohtani two winters ago, which doesn’t happen accidentally. Additionally, Blue Jays fans seem very nice and Canada is geographically close to Minnesota. Unfortunately, they do employ a few too many former Guardians for my taste (Bieber, Clement, Santander, Gimenez, Straw, Sandlin) so they’re left with a solid 9.
FINAL SCORE: 37/50
Seattle Mariners
Twins Connections: 6/10
- Jorge Polanco: 10 seasons with Twins
- Mitch Garver: 5 seasons with Twins
- Donovan Solano: 1 season with Twins
- Luke Raley/Casey Legumina: Former Twins prospects
You can’t tell the story of recent Twins success without Jorge Polanco so he gets a heavier weight. Additionally, Garver’s 2019 breakout where he hit 31 bombas in just 93 games was a highlight of a season full of them. And Solano was instrumental in 2023’s long-awaited curse-breaking postseason win, though he was cut a month ago and Garver barely plays, which knocks them down despite Polanco’s great season.
Entertainment: 8/10
Cal Raleigh just had the best catcher season in MLB history and is giving Aaron Judge a run for his money in the AL MVP race. Julio Rodriguez is the embodiment of baseball fun. Randy Arozarena is a historically elite October hitter. And Josh Naylor, Eugenio Suarez, JP Crawford, Polanco, and Garver are capable of getting hot and carrying the team by themselves. Their starting staff of Woo, Gilbert, Kirby, Miller, and Castillo might be the best in baseball, but one of them will need to pitch out of the bullpen.
In the bullpen, Andres Munoz is probably the best closer in baseball right now. Matt Brash has one of the 5 best breaking balls in MLB. And Eduard Bazardo and Gabe Speier have quietly turned in solid seasons on the middle of Seattle’s relief corps. Brash and Munoz are just wild enough to keep things interesting at the end of games too.
Ethical Ball: 9/10
The Mariners targeted their main ethical weak points at the trade deadline, acquiring Naylor and Suarez from the Diamondbacks to bring some much-needed power to their lineup. They could use some work on the speed and defense side with JP Crawford having a down year in the field and on the bases, while Jorge Polanco’s return to the field took exciting rookie Cole Young out of the lineup.
On the pitching side, they unquestionably have the aces, but have the difficult task of deciding which of the four gets bumped from the rotation and run the risk of choosing incorrectly. They also feel a reliever short, but Bryce Miller or Luis Castillo could potentially fix that.
Recent World Series: 10/10
The Mariners have never won the World Series OR the AL pennant and just on their first division title since 2001. If these guys aren’t a 10, then who is?
Intangibles: 6/10
While the Mariners have shown a willingness to invest in the team in recent seasons, longtime GM Jerry Dipoto is responsible for saying out loud the thing many baseball fans hate: that the main goal of the franchise is to win 54% of your games over a 10 year period, which is an 87 win pace. While mathematically that does make sense now with the expanded playoff field, it’s not something you want to hear from the person leading your franchise. HUGE demerit there.
However, the Seattle Mariners are famously not the New York Yankees, have never employed Aroldis Chapman, and only employ a single former Guardian (Naylor). Good recovery, Seattle.
FINAL SCORE: 39/50
Cleveland Guardians
Twins Connections: 1/10
- Carlos Santana: 1 season with Twins
- Sam Hentges: from Arden Hills, MN
- Derek Falvey: former assistant GM
Carlos Santana is now on the Cubs after getting cut earlier this season. Sam Hentges is out for the year after undergoing knee surgery. Falvey just had four terrible collapses in five seasons and got promoted as a result. Go Tigers!
Entertainment: 1/10
If I can borrow a phrase from a Tweet I currently can’t find, the Guardians’ lineup is Jose Ramirez and a bunch of raccoons in a trench coat. Ramirez is incredible and one of two players (Kyle Manzardo) in the lineup hitting above league average. The collective wRC+ of the 10 players with at least 300 plate appearances besides Ramirez and Manzardo is 82, the same as Brooks Lee’s 2025 total. They’ve scored the fewest runs in baseball, hit the ball weaker than any other team by a wide margin, and do it while claiming that they’re playing the game the “right way.” These guys suck.
Things aren’t much better on the pitching side. Star closer Emmanuel Clase is pseudo-suspended while the league is investigating him for gambling. Cade Smith is incredible as their next man up, but this isn’t the Cleveland baseball you got used to in the 2010s. Gavin Williams is prone to walk 5 batters in any start, Tanner Bibee gets hit around, and everything behind them is smoke and mirrors. This is a bad baseball team who is incredibly unenjoyable to watch who used devil’s magic to win the AL Central with a -6 run differential.
Ethical Ball: 1/10
Guardians players, fans, and social media are going to try to make you think that because they don’t hit home runs or strike out that they play an ethical brand of baseball. Don’t believe them. There’s nothing ethical about grounding out to short in every single at-bat. Don’t fall for the propaganda!!
Also, in terms of real life ethics, Clase and Luis L. Ortiz are currently being investigated for gambling on baseball and fixing pitch outcomes, the cardinal sin of sports. There’s nothing to like about the Cleveland Guardians.
Recent World Series: 6/10
Sure, Cleveland hasn’t won a World Series since 1948 or a pennant since 2016, but they’re a postseason mainstay and just went to the ALCS last season. Also, I don’t like them and I’m writing this article. It already pains me that I can’t give them the lowest total score imaginable, so I was just looking for any excuse I can to knock them down a few pegs.
Intangibles: 1/10
Cleveland may not be the Yankees, but they score terrible marks in every other relevant category. Their ownership is perfectly aligned with the Pohlads, perhaps even to a more extreme degree. The Guardians have never employed Aroldis Chapman, but are the former longtime employers of both Mike Clevinger and Trevor Bauer, two of the all around worst people in the sport. Also, famously, every player on the roster is a future former Guardian. Add on the fact that their fans are quite unpleasant and Progressive Field having a terrible in-game experience, and that’s how you get a 1 in this game.
FINAL SCORE: 10/50 (but spiritually, even lower)
New York Yankees
Twins Connections: 2/10
- Brent Headrick: 2 seasons with Twins
- Ian Hamilton: 1 season with Twins
- Luis Gil: Former Twins prospect
- James Rowson: Former Twins hitting coach
Unfortunately, the only active former Twin with the Yankees is the hitting coach. Headrick is on the IL, Gil may have a chance to start if the Yankees advance, but his performance in 11 starts after returning from injury was underwhelming. Twins connections are poor, plus we hate them so that’s not ideal.
Entertainment: 9/10
Hate him if you want, but Aaron Judge is so fun to watch. He’s the best hitter since Barry Bonds and puts up video game numbers every year. Then he goes around and looks lost in the playoffs. He also can’t throw after an elbow injury a month ago, which the fates have foretold will cost the Yankees a game at some point this postseason. It’s going to be a great time. Add in a vintage Giancarlo Stanton performance, bounce backs from Cody Bellinger and Jazz Chisholm Jr., and breakout seasons from Trent Grisham and Ben Rice and these Yankees unquestionably have a fun lineup.
Max Fried and Carlos Rodon lead a strong rotation for the Yankees, and another prophecy has been revealed that a broadcaster will stumble over Cam Schlittler’s name, who has been very good in his own right. The revamped bullpen with David Bednar, Camilo Doval, and holdovers Devin Williams, Luke Weaver, and Fernando Cruz have all either been lockdown late inning options or absolute disasters. I regret to inform you this team is one of the most entertaining in the field.
Ethical Ball: 7/10
The Yankees are lacking a bit in the speed side for their starting lineups, but make up for it with Jose Caballero, Amed Rosario, and Jasson Dominguez on the bench. Fried and Rodon are as good of a 1-2 combo in the playoff field, with solid options behind them. The bullpen has been elite of late, but could fall apart quickly, knocking them down a couple more pegs.
Recent World Series: 3/10
Sure, New York hasn’t won it all since 2009, but they were in the World Series last season and their fans are so entitled to championships that I find it hard to award them anything higher than a 3. They’re postseason mainstays and that won’t be changing anytime soon.
Intangibles: 3/10
The Yankees simply love to employ Aroldis Chapman, acquiring him on two separate occasions and having him on the team for 7 seasons. Brian Cashman has his issues, but you never have to doubt his commitment to doing what it takes to win. They only employ a single former Guardian (Rosario), but their fans are simply the worst. Also, and most crucially, they are the New York Yankees. Tough look.
FINAL SCORE: 24/50
Boston Red Sox
Twins Connections: 3/10
- Jorge Alcala: 7 seasons with Twins
- Jovani Moran: 4 seasons with Twins
- Liam Hendriks: 3 seasons with Twins
- Michael Fulmer/Rob Refsnyder/Jose De Leon: 1 season with Twins
- Nick Burdi: Former Twins prospect
- Craig Breslow (POBO): 3 seasons with Twins
- Justin Willard (Pitching development): Former Twins coach
- Jarren Duran: future Twin (probably)
Despite a relatively robust list of Twins connections, Boston’s group includes two players no longer in the organization (Alcala, Fulmer), two unlikely to be on the postseason roster (Moran, De Leon), one injured player who is out for the season (Hendriks), one who hasn’t yet played for the Twins (Duran), leaving only two people behind the scenes and a short-side platoon bat (Refsnyder). Burdi is not on the 40-man roster, but would still receive a ring since he pitched a few innings for the Sox early this season.
Entertainment: 5/10
The Red Sox have been decimated by injury and still snuck into the five seed thanks to collapses from Tigers, Twins, Orioles, Rays, and Rangers. What’s left isn’t all that pretty, but there’s still some potential for fireworks. The biggest loss is rookie phenom Roman Anthony, who compiled 2.7 fWAR with a 140 wRC+ in 71 games before an oblique injury shut him down. He could potentially return in mid-October, but the Red Sox will have a lot of work to do to get that far.
While the Red Sox may not have many better hitters than the Guardians, they get a slight pass for it not being the primary plan. Jarren Duran and Alex Bregman are fun, but everyone around them is a liability offensively. Masataka Yoshida and his 88 wRC+ is their regular cleanup batter, while players like Cedanne Rafaela, Wilyer Abreu, and Carlos Narvaez are valuable for their contributions elsewhere, not necessarily at the plate.
The pitching staff is similarly in disarray. If I may borrow a phrase from the Guardians’ section and still a Tweet that I can’t remember, Boston’s pitchers are Garrett Crochet, Aroldis Chapman, and a bunch of raccoons in a trench coat. Garrett Whitlock has some juice too, and Crochet is one of my favorite pitchers to watch, but there’s only so much they can do. A lack of lineup depth means their pitching needs to be elite to make a run, and I just don’t think they have quite enough at this point.
Ethical Ball: 4/10
A healthier roster would rate
significantly higher, but missing the power from Triston Casas, Roman Anthony, and Marcelo Mayer leaves the lineup wanting. Their role players would be perfect with better hitters around them, but as it stands they are pressed into spots above their pay grade.
The exact same can be said for the pitching staff. Kutter Crawford, Hunter Dobbins, Tanner Houck, Richard Fitts, Jordan Hicks, and Liam Hendriks leave them a few arms short despite dominance from Crochet and Chapman.
Recent World Series: 2/10
The Red Sox won it all in 2018 for the second time in five seasons and the fourth time in the previous 14. While 2018 was a while ago at this point, Red Sox fans, and Boston sports fans in general, have been spoiled with titles over the past 20 years, with the Celtics, Patriots, and Bruins all winning multiple championships. The Dodgers are the only team in 2025’s playoff field that have won a World Series more recently.
Intangibles: 3/10
The Red Sox ownership group is one of a handful of billionaires trying their best to ruin professional sports. The Fenway Sports group is more interested in spending money on the Liverpool Football Club than the Red Sox, while trading away Mookie Betts, Rafael Devers, and others while claiming financial hardship as one of the biggest, most valuable sports franchises in the world. They’ve begun to reverse course the last couple seasons, acquiring and extending players like Anthony, Crochet, Bello, Rafaela, and Yoshida.
Unfortunately for them, one of the other players they signed to a big extension is Aroldis Chapman, earning them a double demerit both for signing him in the first place and then extending him. Also Jarren Duran simply loves yelling slurs at fans. Thankfully, the Red Sox are not the Yankees and get one of those points back for also being their main rival. They also get some credit for Fenway Park being very cool and playoff games at Fenway being an elite experience.
FINAL SCORE: 17/50 (we’re all surprised this is lower than the Yankees, honestly)
Detroit Tigers
Twins Connections: 2/10
- Chris Paddack: 4 seasons with Twins
- Kenta Maeda: 4 seasons with Twins
- Manuel Margot/Dietrich Enns: 1 season with Twins
- Akil Baddoo/Sawyer Gipson-Long: Former Twins prospects
Everyone listed would get rings if the Tigers win it all, but Maeda was released months ago and Paddack didn’t make Detroit’s postseason roster after a terrible showing post-trade deadline. Margot had a forgettable year in Minnesota and Dietrich Enns played for the Ron Gardenhire Twins in 2016, and is now on the Orioles. Not a lot of Twins representation here.
Entertainment: 6/10
If Garrett Crochet isn’t the best pitcher in the AL, Tarik Skubal is. Skubal is a bonafide ace who puts on a show every time he takes the mound. A weak, yet exciting bullpen behind him will make for some good swings late in the game as long as the bats can keep up with the runs allowed in the late innings. Riley Greene, Spencer Torkelson, and Kerry Carpenter are capable of hitting a ball 500 feet every time they’re at the plate, while Javier Baez is going to do
something entertaining in every game, for good or bad. Add in the fact that they’re trying to wash away their late season collapse to the hapless Guardians, and these guys make for some fun storylines, even if the players themselves are underwhelming.
Ethical Ball: 5/10
Offensively, these guys play some strong ethical ball. It’s dragged down a bit by one of their key defense/speed role players being the highly-paid Baez, but overall the lineup has a strong showing in every category with good balance. Pitching is where things fall off, as the rotation behind Skubal and the entire bullpen is incredibly suspect. Former #1 pick Casey Mize can be hit or miss and no one has known what to do with Jack Flaherty for about five years now. They’re walking on eggshells after Skubal.
Recent World Series: 7/10
The Detroit Tigers haven’t won a World Series since 1984 and have been among the worst in the league for the past decade, essentially since those peak Miguel Cabrera, Justin Verlander, Victor Martinez squads. It would be fun to see the Tigers get a ring, but there are others more deserving.
Intangibles: 5/10
POBO Scott Harris aligns perfectly with the Pohlad view of spending on a baseball team. Their outright refusal to spend any significant resources on pitching put them in this exact spot, though they’re not as bad as Cleveland. They aren’t the Yankees, have never employed Aroldis Chapman, and only employ a single former Guardian (Paul Sewald) who was barely on the team. A good bounce back despite Harris’ best efforts.
FINAL SCORE: 25/50
The Seattle Mariners and the load-bearing Jorge Polanco come out on top with 39 out of a possible 50 points, narrowly edging out the Blue Jays, who may have had a stronger case if Jose Berrios was available. We’ll be back tomorrow with the NL version and to crown a champion of the Twins fan postseason guide!