Peyton Manning vs. Eli Manning

Poll Poll Who would you rather have on your team? Peyton Manning or Eli Manning?

  • Peyton Manning

    Votes: 2 100.0%

  • Eli Manning

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    2
Peyton Manning. He's older, and probably in worse shape, but he is easily the best QB in the league right now. I'm not sure how long that will last, but for now, I'd pick Peyton in a heartbeat.
 
The problem with Peyton is that he has a well document history of failing in games that matter. Basically, he sucks in the playoffs. He isn't clutch. Peyton Manning is always a beast during the regular season, but other than Super Bowl XLI, he has found ways to lose in the playoffs. Eli Manning is the opposite. We are seeing him play horrible right now, but he usually turns things around by the end of the season and into the playoffs. He isn't going to be in the playoffs this year, but his two Super Bowl rings support what I am saying. :P

I still think I would take Peyton over Eli, but I feel like I am one of the few people that think this is a legitimate debate. Peyton Manning owns Eli when it comes to statistics, but Eli Manning is clutch.
 
That might be true, but what good is doing well in the playoffs if you can't make it to them?
 
2091401 said:
That might be true, but what good is doing well in the playoffs if you can't make it to them?
Click to expand...

Eli Manning has made it to the playoffs five time, and he has two Super Bowl rings to show for it. Clearly, he can make it to them. :P
 
2787cmt said:
2091401 said:
That might be true, but what good is doing well in the playoffs if you can't make it to them?
Click to expand...

Eli Manning has made it to the playoffs five time, and he has two Super Bowl rings to show for it. Clearly, he can make it to them. :P
Click to expand...
Well yeah, of course, but I mean as of now. Eli Manning might not be the only reason his team is 2-6, but he's not doing much to help them either.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top