Denver Broncos
Role Player
Grading the Broncos’ 2025 draft class
Source: https://www.milehighreport.com/2025/4/26/24418300/denver-broncos-2025-draft-grades
![]()
Mike Watters-Imagn Images
Here’s how we grade the Denver Broncos 2025 NFL Draft class. They picked seven players over the three event.
Draft weekend has finally concluded and we’re here to give you our draft grades for the Denver Broncos 2025 draft class. I think we all acknowledge that these grades are pretty meaningless considering none of these players have taken a single NFL snap, but that’s just what we prognosticators and draft nuts do the day after the draft concludes.
Personally, this draft went nowhere close to where I expected it from Sean Payton and George Paton. They kept us on our toes with four total trades and picks that no one expected. However, I think I’d still give them an overall ‘B’ grade for this draft class. The hit the needs they needed to hit and they secured some great value players at already strong position groups.
Here is where everyone else at Mile High Report landed on draft weekend:
Grade: A
I give the Broncos an A for this draft. I think they got great value at all levels of the draft based on who they got and how they fit with the team (because I largely don’t care about the draft boards the unclean masses use). I can see a vision for each player the Broncos picked up. I think they have some starting talent, special teams players, and developmental guys with their picks, which makes sense for our roster as it stands today. The Broncos also masterfully worked the draft making multiple trades and gaining value at the end of the day. George Paton and Sean Payton knocked it out of the park. - Sadaraine
Grade: A+
A+. Draft grades are dumb and judging a draft before the players even take part in a practice with the team never made sense to me. They got themselves a talented corner, an explosive runner, a WR who fits the scheme, two developmental defensive players, the best punter in the draft, and a freaky TE prospect to end the draft.Nobody knows anything. Let’s hope for the best. A+. - Scotty Payne
Grade: C
The Broncos came out of the 2025 NFL Draft by addressing both immediate and long-term needs. We won’t know the true value of this class until a few years down the road. I am a big fan of the Jahdae Barron, Sai’vion Jones, and Que Robinson selections. Those guys all have a shot to be really good players on defense. On offense, I can see the vision with RJ Harvey and Pat Bryant, though I felt they came off the board a little bit earlier than expected and would have preferred other players at the position.
I like that they took a punter as well, but I’m still scratching my head over the Caleb Lohner pick. There were a multitude of prospects with extensive collegiate experience and the Broncos decided to bet on the athletic upside of a former basketball player that caught four balls in one year of college football. I’m sure some fans will point to Julius Thomas or Antonio Gates as reasons for optimism, but I’ll pass on that Kool-Aid. - Chris Hart
Grade: B+
I like that they let the draft come to them at #20 and ended up with a guy they thought would be off the board by then. Corner wasn’t a big perceived need, but when you pair this pick the acquisitions of Greenlaw and Hufanga, their box coverage has gone from the biggest weakness on their defense to potentially a strength.
Day 2 I just wanted skill players for Bo and I’ll trust Sean Payton on the specifics. I do like that we can see clear Payton prototypes with a Kamara and Michael Thomas style players.
I’ll never turn down more pass rush talent being added to the stable and we’ll see on the punter and Lohner. Rounds 6 & 7 should be treated as secured UDFAs anyway, so not expecting much there.
Overall, I liked the trading around for better slotting and Paton got good value from the moves. They clearly targeted guys who were team captains with clear college production in the higher rounds, which I love.
These type of drafts won’t get a ton of fanfare compared to one where you draft a rookie of the year candidate, but these are the kind that pay off in a few years when contracts start coming due and you need a balanced roster with starters contributing on cheap deals. - Jeff Essary
Grade: B+
This might have been one of the most unexpected drafts that I can remember. Myself and most of Broncos Country were way off on who Denver would draft, but that’s not a bad thing. The Broncos made some sneaky good picks on Day 2 and they rounded things out nicely on Day 3. Payton and Paton were cooking with some savvy moves to gain some extra capital. While I wish they drafted an offensive lineman late, they’ve been signing a bunch in free agency. And I hope that the scouts are right about Jones being able to play the interior as well.
I’m really excited to get to rookie minicamp and then the season to see what these dudes can do. This defense has tons of potential. - Ross Allen
Source: https://www.milehighreport.com/2025/4/26/24418300/denver-broncos-2025-draft-grades