New Jersey Devils
Role Player
Devils Free Agency Targets: Centers
Source: https://www.allaboutthejersey.com/2...ersey-devils-2025-free-agency-targets-centers
![]()
John Tavares and Sam Bennett are the two top UFA centers available this summer | Photo by Claus Andersen/Getty Images
The Devils need to add another center. The good news is that there are several available. The bad news is that its not a deep market and they don’t have a lot of flexibility with which to add one.
After looking at the New Jersey Devils own free agents over the last few weeks, the time has come to take a look around the league and see who else will become available.
Including the recently signed Arseni Gritsyuk, as well as an otherwise waste of a roster spot in Kurtis MacDermid, the Devils have 11 forwards under contract for next season that will presumably be on the NHL roster. Judging from that, it doesn’t sound like the Devils have much work to do upfront, but when one considers that they might move on from Erik Haula, Ondrej Palat, and others, the Devils actually have plenty of work to do as they try to add more speed and skill upfront, as well as assemble a functional bottom six.
My colleagues will cover the other positions and free agents in the coming days and weeks, but today, we will start with arguably the most important skater position on the ice and take a look at centers.
The Devils have two excellent centers in Nico Hischier and Jack Hughes. But we have seen their center depth be tested in recent years between Hughes’s shoulder injuries, Erik Haula’s decline, and the team never bothering to replace Michael McLeod. This has forced Nico Hischier into carrying a heavy workload where he plays in all situations and takes every key faceoff, and while Hischier is more than capable, you’d like for the Devils to get him a little help to take some of those responsibilities off of his plate. Cody Glass might have been a decent add in-season to be a potential bottom six center option, but I’m sure he was far from being Tom Fitzgerald’s first choice either. Even if Glass returns next year, the Devils need more.
Center is a hard position to find quality options, and its not a coincidence or an accident that the teams remaining in the playoffs are deep down the middle. Anton Lundell would be a burgeoning 1C or 2C on most teams but he’s Florida’s 3C due to their depth. Dallas has an embarrassment of riches down the middle to the point where one of the top UFA centers hitting the market this summer is actually playing LW for them. Carolina is deep enough where their centers behind Sebastian Aho are more or less interchangeable depending upon the matchup. It’s also not a coincidence that all of the recent Stanley Cup champions have been deep down the middle, whether its Vegas, Tampa, or Colorado. Having quality center play is critical to having a quality third or fourth line, and that is critical to having success.
The good news for the Devils is that there’s several good options this year in the UFA market. The bad news is that those options will dry up quickly (if they all even make it to July 1) and for a team with a limited amount of cap space, spending most of it to address one need when you have several isn’t a great plan. But we’re going to take a look at who is available anyways and determine whether or not they might make sense for a Devils team that really needs more quality forwards if they hope to take that next step as a franchise. We’ll take a look at Top Six options as well as Bottom Six options. I’ll also provide the AFP Analytics contract projections to get a sense of what a deal for each player might look like.
John Tavares
It wasn’t too long ago that John wrote about how the Devils should consider pursuing John Tavares when he hit free agency way back in 2018.
Tavares leaving the Islanders to head to the Devils was never a realistic possibility though at the time, as New Jersey didn’t make his short list of teams he was considering, and the Devils certainly weren’t the team represented on his bedsheets as a young boy in Canada. Tavares wanted to be a Maple Leaf. The Maple Leafs wanted him. And hence, Tavares became a Leaf and got to live his boyhood dream.
But was it everything Tavares dreamed of?
Sure, Tavares got to spend seven years playing for what is essentially his hometown team. He was highly productive with 493 points in 515 games. He showed he has plenty left in the tank with 38 goals and 36 assists this past season. He’s a faceoff winning machine that is getting better as he gets older. And until this past season, he served as the captain of the Maple Leafs before passing that torch to Auston Matthews.
Unfortunately, Tavares has also become one of the faces of the postseason failures of the Maple Leafs “Core Four”. Fairly or unfairly, he alongside Auston Matthews, William Nylander, and Mitch Marner have to bear the brunt of those critiques as the leaders of the team. And while Tavares’s postseason numbers as a whole look ok this past season, two goals in seven games against Florida en route to a series loss (and zero over the final four games) will get you criticized.
I say all that to say, has Toronto been everything Tavares wanted? After seven years of playing in that pressure cooker, has he had his fill? And do the Leafs even want him back?
I don’t really care about the Leafs perspective of all of this, and judging from Tavares’s comments on breakup day, it sounds like he’s open to running it back in Toronto anyways, so everything I just wrote might be moot. It wouldn’t surprise me at the end of the day if he agreed to an extension to stay. But when you’re this close to free agency and the emotional highs and lows of the season wear off once you’re several weeks removed from elimination, you’d also be wise to at least see what else is out there and see what your options are.
I have no doubt that there will be demand for the services of one John Tavares. Even if you think his run as the Leafs captain is ultimately a stain on his record, PPG-caliber centers don’t grow on trees. There’s not a lot of hockey players who have scored 500+ goals in NHL history, but Tavares will likely be the next to join that club. He clearly has something left in the tank.
AFP Analytics Projection: 3 years, $7.939M AAV
Why he could work: This is one of those situations where I would be very curious what Sheldon Keefe thinks of the player.
Obviously, there is a connection there as Keefe was the head coach throughout much of Tavares’ tenure in Toronto. And while I think Tavares is enough of a pro to not let comments from Keefe about a lack of accountability bother him, it is one of those situations where I do wonder if after having a front row seat for years if Keefe wants back in the Tavares business. Still, Keefe is very familiar with Tavares. Keefe and Tavares had a lot of regular season success together. And the Devils still have to navigate an 82-game regular season. Perhaps if they navigate the regular season better, they might avoid a playoff date with Carolina one of these years.
There are very few Top Six caliber centers available this summer on the open market. Tavares is one of them.
Why he probably won’t work: Tavares will turn 35 before Opening Night this fall, his footspeed is already in decline, he got exposed defensively at various points this postseason, and fair or not, his postseason disappearances are a thing. And while New Jersey is a far quieter hockey hotbed than Toronto, it won’t matter to Devils fans if Tavares doesn’t perform in that type of environment. It’ll just be another black mark on what is becoming a long list of shortcomings as a player.
Sam Bennett
Let’s have some fun with blind resumes for a second.
Player A: 162 goals, 174 assists, 336 points in 691 games. 34 goals and 36 assists for 70 points in 99 playoff games. One Stanley Cup championship.
Player B: 143 goals, 280 assists, 423 points in 628 games. 48 goals and 46 assists for 94 points in 138 playoff games. Two Stanley Cup championships.
Player A is obviously Sam Bennett, a player most Devils fans are salivating over after watching him be a factor in yet another deep playoff run for the Florida Panthers and would happily hand a blank check to if they could this summer.
Player B is a player Devils fans can’t wait to get rid of.
It’s Ondrej Palat, prior to him signing in New Jersey three years ago.
Now, its not a perfect comparison. Bennett is a center. Palat is not. Bennett is hitting free agency three years younger than Palat did. But Bennett also plays a far heavier and abrasive brand of hockey than Palat does. Bennett is also going to command max term unlike Palat, and if you think Years 1-3 of Palat’s Devils run didn’t look good, I would hazard a guess that Years 5-7 of a Bennett deal wouldn’t fare much better. Playing with that level of physicality does take its toll at some point.
I don’t want this to come across as me disparaging Bennett as a player. I love what he brings to the table. He’s a big game player who also plays an abrasive style that is well suited for postseason hockey. The Devils could use more players like Sam Bennett.
I’m going to write more about this at some point this summer, but he’s very much a “16 game player” as opposed to an “82 game player”. What do I mean by that? It means he’s a guy who shows up in the biggest games and it almost doesn’t matter what he does over the course of the regular season. Guys like Bennett, or Mark Stone, or Val Nichushkin are “16 game players”. So was Palat, once upon a time.
Devils Insiders ran an interesting poll regarding Bennett versus another top free agent this summer and I’m pleased to say that I am one of the 55.4% of people on the right side of history.
Cap aside, you can add one of Marner or Bennett to the #NJDevils this offseason. Who do you choose? Why?
— Devils Insiders (@DevilsInsiders) May 20, 2025
Regardless, Bennett has been a big part of Florida’s success the last few years. He has been a key contributor to three teams that have made deep playoff runs. It’s not going to matter that his career high for goals in a season is 28 (three years ago) or that his career high in points is 51 (this past season). He is going to get paid by somebody.
AFP Analytics Projection: 6 years, $6.637M AAV
Why he could work: Bennett is very much an “identity” player, and the Devils need more of those types throughout their lineup. He can capably play anywhere in the Top Nine of a playoff contender on either center or wing. He has a ton of big game experience and plays with an extremely high motor.
Why he probably won’t work: Bennett isn’t going to put up gaudy point totals over the course of an 82 game season, and if he takes a step back in that regard playing outside of Florida, the contract will look like one of the worst in the sport. He simply HAS to produce come playoff time for him to be worth it.
If you’re the type of has been grumbling about Palat being a 30-ish point player since joining the Devils, you probably won’t be too thrilled when Bennett is making more money for far longer and is barely a 40-point player. Also, I don’t buy that particular AFP projection for one second. Bennett is a high profile player on a team that has made three straight deep playoff runs. He is going to get paid. I think his AAV is going to be closer to 9, and it just takes one dumb, desperate team to go north of that. And if he accepts less than that, its probably because he’s taking a sweetheart deal to stay in Florida, not to come to New Jersey.
Brock Nelson
A lifelong Islander until this past season, Brock Nelson split his time between Elmont and Colorado as the Avalanche acquired him at the trade deadline. Colorado was desperate to upgrade their center depth. But was Nelson an upgrade?
Kind of? But probably not.
Nelson is a big body at 6’4” and 210 lb.,he has remained productive offensively with 26 goals and 30 assists this past season, and he’s still a good skater for a player of his size. But he didn’t have a great playoff series against Dallas and it seems to be the worst kept secret in the league that the Minnesota native might want to go home to Minnesota.
AFP Analytics Projection: 3 years, $7.06M AAV
Why he could work: A bad playoff series shouldn’t necessarily define the player. The Devils need more speed in their lineup and they need a guy who can put the puck in the net. Nelson checks those boxes and plays a position of need to boot.
Why he probably won’t work: The Prudential Center is not located in Minnesota. Nelson also turns 34 this October, and has plenty of wear on his tires already with 1005 games played between the regular season and postseason. I’m not saying he’s about to fall off of a cliff in terms of production, but I’d rather pursue other options than commit to Nelson for multiple years and noteworthy money.
Matt Duchene
Matt Duchene has quietly been one of the best bargains in the NHL for the last two years.
After signing a 7-year, $56M deal with the Nashville Predators in 2019, the Predators bought him out four years into that pact. Duchene landed on his feet in Dallas, finishing the second of two separate one-year, $3M deals this past season.
Duchene has continued to produce though even though he approaches his mid 30s. He’s tallied 55 goals and 92 assists with the Stars over the last two seasons.
AFP Analytics Projection: 3 years, $7.17M AAV
Why he could work: He’s really good, and while he’d be overqualified to be a 3C type, he would go a long ways towards making the Devils deeper down the middle.
Why he probably won’t work: He has even more miles on the odometer than Nelson when it comes to games played and turns 35 in January. He is also currently in an excellent situation in Dallas where he is a perfect fit in Pete DeBoer’s system and he plays a prominent role on a team that has a legitimate chance to win a Stanley Cup. I don’t see why he would leave other than some team blows him away in terms of money, but he’s still collecting a paycheck from the Predators in addition to what he’s making in Dallas. If he continues to take under market value deals, it would likely be to stay where he is.
Mikael Granlund
A 13-year veteran, Granlund split his time this season with the Sharks and the Stars. In totality, he played 83 regular season games, registering 22 goals and 44 assists between the two teams. His production wasn’t solely a byproduct of playing 21 minutes a night on a bad Sharks team either, as he had 7 goals and 14 assists in 31 games in Dallas post-trade and has been a playoff contributor as well.
The interesting thing with Granlund is that he hasn’t played much center since going to Dallas, as he’s settled in on their top, all-Finnish line with Roope Hintz and Mikko Rantanen. But I think that’s more a testament to what Dallas has down the middle between Hintz, Matt Duchene, and Wyatt Johnston than anything with him in particular. That type of flexibility affords Dallas the opportunity to throw several different looks at opposing teams depending upon the matchup.
Granlund is a little older at 33, but he should come with a more affordable contract than some of the previous names I’ve already mentioned.
AFP Analytics Projection: 2 years, $4.975M AAV
Why he could work: Granlund might be 33, but he has plenty of offensive skill and enough versatility where he can feasibly slot anywhere in the Top Nine.
Why he probably won’t work: He’s had three 60+ point seasons over the last four years, so he’s going to cost money. He’s also in a really good situation in Dallas, so if he does take a discount, it would presumably be for someone like them and not a Devils team where he has no ties or connections to.
Jack Roslovic
Now, we’re getting into more of your 3C and 4C territory.
Roslovic has been a journeyman with previous stops in Winnipeg, Columbus, and New York before signing a 1-year $2.8M deal with Carolina this past season.
Roslovic has been relatively productive, with point totals of 45, 44, 31, and 39 over the last four seasons. He has some size at 6’1” and is a decent enough skater.
AFP Analytics Projection: 3 years, $4.09M AAV
Why he could work: Roslovic has put up decent counting stats regardless of the environment around him the last few years. He’s a better skater than most of the players on this list. I also think this is another one of those instances where the AFP projection is wrong and you could probably get the player for something closer to 2-years and $2.5M AAV.
Why he probably won’t work: Roslovic isn’t overly physical, which is interesting after playing a full season in Carolina’s heavy forecheck system. He’s also been a healthy scratch for playoff games for Carolina during this run. Maybe that’s a testament to Carolina’s depth down the middle, as they have Aho, Staal, Kotkaniemi, and Mark Janikowski, but Roslovic also has a history of being so-so in the playoffs prior to getting to Carolina and there wasn’t a huge demand for his services one year ago on the open market.
Yanni Gourde
Yanni Gourde returned to the Tampa Bay Lightning at the trade deadline after spending most of the previous 3.5 seasons with the Seattle Kraken.
Gourde was a key member of the Lightning third line, along with Blake Coleman and Barclay Goodrow, that helped get Tampa over the hump and win back-to-back Stanley Cup championships. He has plenty of experience in big games. But his production has dipped a bit these last two seasons as he enters his mid 30s, he underwent sports hernia surgery during the year, and was mostly ineffective in a quick playoff exit for Tampa Bay last month.
AFP Analytics Projection: 2 years, $3.789M AAV
Why he could work: If you think Gourde dealing with a hernia hampered him, but now that issue has been fixed, then he theoretically has bounceback potential. And even if he doesn’t become a 48 point player again, a 40 ish point season is still an upgrade over what the Devils had from their third line center one year ago.
Why he probably won’t work: Gourde turns 34 this December, has lost a step or two already, players generally don’t get healthier as they age, and the last time the Devils signed a 30-something year old for intangibles reasons from Tampa, it didn’t really work out. He’s also one of the smaller centers on this list at 5’9” and 174 lb.
Pius Suter
Suter might be the most interesting name on this list for me.
Suter took a step offensively this year in his age 28 season, scoring 25 goals and chipping in another 21 assists. He’s not a large player at 5’11” and 180 lb. but he had shown a willingness to get to the front of the net, take some punishment, and make things happen.
Part of why he intrigues me though is his work as a defensive center, as he’s been a key member of Vancouver’s penalty kill. I see that, and I see how many defensive responsibilities that Nico Hischier has, and am intrigued by the idea that Suter could give the Devils another option in that regard.
AFP Analytics Projection: 4 years, $4.983M AAV
Why he could work: He has some finishing ability, he’s excellent defensively, and he plays bigger than his frame.
Why he probably won’t work: Suter is probably a smidge more than I’d like to pay for a 3C if those AFP projections are close to accurate. He’s also not a great skater, nor is he really a playmaker by nature. I’d at least be a little concerned that his 18.1 shooting percentage from this past season isn’t repeatable.
Quick Thoughts on Some Other Bottom Six UFA Centers
Christian Dvorak: Dvorak is probably more of a middle six guy than your run of the mill bottom six center. He had a decent year with 33 points in 82 games for Montreal this past season, has decent size, and is pretty good in the faceoff circle. But he doesn’t really drive play, isn’t going to add much on special teams, and probably has enough of a track record to be more expensive than your run of the mill option. Maybe he has a little more to give as a 3C on a deeper team than Montreal that has quality wingers on the third line, but I don’t know if NJ is that team unless they insist on playing Meier or Bratt with him. That said, his AFP projection of 2 years and $1.765M AAV makes him an interesting flier candidate, assuming that is his actual price tag. I have my doubts.
Radek Faksa: Faksa is a big body, defense-first, faceoff specialist who won’t contribute much offensively but would be a massive upgrade over the Justin Dowling/Curtis Lazar types. AFP projection: 2 years, $1.33M
Luke Kunin: Kunin is a physical 4C who doesn’t contribute much else of anything, and didn’t really help Columbus after coming over at the trade deadline from San Jose. He is capable of scoring 10 or so goals over the course of the year, but he also gives it all bad with poor defensive play. He’s probably not worth his 2-year, $1.78M AAV projected contract.
Lars Eller: Eller is another big-body bottom six center who was ok after coming back to Washington via an early season trade from the Penguins. He’ll win his share of faceoffs, but he’s not particularly physical, he didn’t do much of anything in the playoffs this year, and he’s entering his age 36 season. I’d pass on him at 1-year and $2.13M
Nick Bjugstad: Bjugstad might be more of a winger than a center if his usage this past season is an indicator, but he’s another guy who is a big body and puts up decent enough counting stats considering he sees little to no special teams time. He also gives the Devils another faceoff option if someone gets tossed from the dot. There are worse uses of 2 years and $2.32M AAV.
Luke Glendening: Glendening is strictly a 4C faceoff option with a little physicality mixed in. He might be a slight upgrade over Dowling but that’s not saying a whole lot. He can probably be had for the league minimum.
Kevin Rooney: Rooney is a former Devil who didn’t do a whole lot well when he was here five years ago, but has managed to stick around the league as a 4C who can kill penalties, throw the occasional hit, and not do much else. He’s another league-minimum candidate.
Tomas Nosek: Another former Devil, he wasn’t exactly an ideal fit the first time around as he is big, slow, and missed a bunch of time due to a broken foot. And no, his 9 points in 59 games for Florida or his 3 assists in 8 playoff games isn’t yet another indicator that Tom Fitzgerald is an idiot for letting him go. AFP is projecting him to make $916k next season.
Sean Kuraly: I don’t know how open Kuraly is to moving, as he’s an Ohio native who has spent the last four seasons in Columbus. But he has decent counting stats, is another big body, can kill penalties, is physical, and is a decent option in the dot. If Columbus lets him walk, he’s an interesting option at 2-years and $1.5M AAV.
Nico Sturm: Sturm is a big-bodied faceoff specialist and that’s about it. If you think that’s worth 2 years and $1.42M AAV, by all means. I do not.
Final Thoughts
After taking a look at the top UFA centers on the market, I have some thoughts on the market and the Devils situation as a whole.
First, even if the Devils had the cap space to afford any of them, I’m not sure how many of them are good ideas. Tavares, Nelson, Duchene, Gourde, and Granlund are older players, each with strengths and flaws. Suter is somewhat interesting as a bottom six option, but has his own flaws as a player. And while I’m as big a fan of Sam Bennett as the next guy, paying top dollar for what is essentially a 40-45 point player at the peak of his value is the type of deal that can put you in cap hell if and when it doesn’t work out.
Second, the Devils probably need to have internal conversations in regards to how much they want to invest in the center position behind Hischier and Hughes. Hughes in particular has missed large chunks of three of the last four seasons with shoulder ailments and for as talented as he is, he’s not doing the Devils any good on the injured list. I’m not saying the Devils should be shopping for his replacement or get rid of him, as those are ill-advised and foolish suggestions. But I am saying that if the Devils are concerned about Hughes internally, then it would make sense to invest more into their 3C so they have other options should the worst case scenario pop up with #86 again.
Third, the cap situation can’t be ignored, and if the Devils are going to make the effort this summer to clean up their books and free up cap space, I think I would prefer they look for potential longer-term solutions to their problems than throwing market value UFA dollars at whoever happens to be available in any given year. But the reality is that their funds are limited this summer, and the more they spend at 3C when they’re already spending over 15M between Hischier/Hughes, the less they’ll have to spend elsewhere.
I say that to say that rather than them signing Sam Bennett as a UFA, I’d rather they go out and try to trade for the next Sam Bennett. Granted, that’s far easier said than done, but we’ve seen plenty of instances of guys who got off to underwhelming starts to their career only to blossom somewhere else, whether its Bennett, Sam Reinhart, Carter Verhaeghe, Mason Marchment, Jordan Martinook, Evan Rodrigues, or whoever. Why can’t the Devils pro scouting department find that next guy and acquire him before they become a household name? It’s not like the Devils haven’t had any success trading for relatively unknown players, with Paul Cotter and Johnathan Kovacevic being two very recent examples. Rather than pay UFA prices, why not see if you can pry Marco Rossi from the Wild when he’s about to enter his age 24 season? Or revisit a potential trade for Ryan O’Reilly at a far lower cap hit? Or explore other outside the box options like Barrett Hayton or Mason McTavish or J.G. Pageau? Get creative.
That’s not to say the players I broke down here are bad players. Frankly, I’d be fine with it if they signed someone like Jack Roslovic to be the 4C, as I’d view him as a massive upgrade over what the Devils currently have and he shouldn’t break the bank. But I don’t view the Devils center depth issue as easily fixable, since it will take time to draft and develop more centers internally and they don’t have their first round pick this year. It will require some short-term attention and resources devoted to addressing it. And considering Jack Hughes’s injury history and Nico Hischier’s UFA status in two years, I would prefer to see the Devils be proactive when it comes to adding more depth at the position so they’re not left in a precarious position. Not just for this upcoming season either, but for the next several years.
Or just sign Pius Suter as the 3C, re-sign Cody Glass as the 4C, and trade Erik Haula. That works too.
That’s how I view the center market. Perhaps you view things differently. Please feel free to leave a comment below and thanks for reading.
Source: https://www.allaboutthejersey.com/2...ersey-devils-2025-free-agency-targets-centers