Carolina Panthers
Team Leader
The Optimist: Signs of LIFE!
Source: https://www.catscratchreader.com/carolina-panthers-scores-results/56267/the-optimist-signs-of-life
![]()
Hello CSR! I’m taking over this week’s version of the Monday Morning Optimist, and I’m very happy to do so. I decided to base my headline on Walker’s post from last week, thanks for letting me hijack this!
The Carolina Panthers defeated the Dallas Cowboys 30-27, an all around great effort that kept the Panthers firmly in “regular season matters” type of football rather than “how is this win/loss going to affect their first round pick” territory. They faced a Cowboys team that hasn’t been the best, but one that has been clawing for divisional/playoff supremacy. The Panthers went punch for punch with this very good offensive team after so many horrifically terrible starts to their games to kick off the season. The Panthers now sit at 3-3, with the ball firmly in their court as far as determining what legacy they will leave for their iteration of 2025. Let’s dive in.
What I Liked
Rico Dowdle-Extremely Optimistic
Rico Dowdle called his shot this week, talking about his former team and how motivated he was to deliver a performance against them. He delivered, with a 30 carry, 183 yard rushing effort supplemented by a 4 catch, 56 yards receiving effort and a score to really nail the Cowboys down. I love Chuba Hubbard, but after the last two weeks Rico has amassed over 400 yards of total scrimmage yards. I can now understand why Dave Canales was mixing him in so much when Chuba was healthy. This offense will do its best work behind a bell-cow running back, and it showed once again on Sunday. He’s now earned the questions that will come once Chuba is fully healthy again, but I think based on how devoted the Panthers have suddenly become to running the ball, there will be plenty of yards to gobble up between the two of them. Rico was one of the value signings many pundits loved of the offseason, and over these last two weeks he’s proved all of them right.
Bryce Young-Optimistic
There will always be peaks and valleys with Bryce, and I get where the fan base is coming from with their criticisms of him, both on the field and in general as far as what he brings to the table. However, Sundays performance (to me) showed what kind of quarterback he can be, which is a guy who can spread the ball around, and get the offensive weapons into positions to succeed. Bryce went into a boxing match with Dak Prescott, and by no means was he perfect. But, he threw nice TD passes when they mattered to Tetairoa McMillan (twice) and Rico Dowdle. He didn’t have to be the engine on Sunday as much as the conductor, and I think that role suits him just fine for what this team and coaching staff is trying to do. Dave Canales isn’t asking him to throw the ball 50 times a game, and he delivered 3 TD passes when the Panthers offense needed him to score points. And he showed up and made the throws they needed in big time moments, such as the crucial 4th down conversion on the final drive to Hunter Renfrow. Bryce Young might not ever be Drew Brees, but if the Panthers continue to run the ball stubbornly like Canales stated he wanted to when they brought him in last year, this conductor role could work quite well!
Offensive Rookies-Extremely Optimistic
Tetairoa McMillan scored twice on a day where the passing offense wasn’t flying all over the place. Jimmy Horn Jr and Mitchell Evans both had catches with real implications on the drives. Trevor Etienne ran a couple of times when the team needed some extra yards without Dowdle on the field. This rookie class as a whole seems to be legit. And they are all contributing in a real way rather than simply because they are the only ones available, which is a far cry from seasons past.
Defense-Holistically Optimistic
The Panthers biggest weakness coming into the season was their defense, and they did their damnedest to try and fix it. The results were mixed throughout the first few weeks, but I think the unit is settling into something. I’m not entirely sure what that is, but through the last two weeks they’ve given up less than 70 yards COMBINED on the ground. This was against teams with very good running backs, even behind suspect offensive line combos. This has allowed the defense to keep the Panthers in the game, and luckily their offense is delivering just enough that they are now 3-3 and control their own destiny. George Pickens picked this defense apart, but when it mattered, this defense was able to make just enough plays against a very good offense.
This iteration of the Panthers is not the roaring defensive juggernauts of the past with several Pro Bowlers on the defensive line and at the linebacker position that we’ve come to enjoy from past memories of this franchise. But we are seeing some core players like Derrick Brown, Jaycee Horn, Tre’Von Moehrig, and Nick Scott push this defense to be greater than the sum of their parts. Christian Rozeboom and Trevin Wallace were once again huge contributors for this defense instead of major issues, something I would not have expected after a dreadful first four weeks of the season. They make mistakes, but keeping a white hot Dallas offense from putting this game out of reach is a major testament to this defense, even without the pass rushing statistics and turnovers you want from a higher end group.
The Panthers managed to beat a Dallas Cowboys team that was very clearly trying to push back to the top of the conference. I’m not going to bother picking at what I didn’t like or feel pessimistic about, the Panthers are on a very rare win streak. Xavier Legette had an ugly play, but I’m not going to hammer him because the Panthers still won. This team won in about the most modern Panthers way possible; ugly smash mouth offense and sound but not flashy defense. Special shout out to the special teams unit as well, they played the field position game quite well on kickoffs, as Ryan Fitzgerald continues to be a weapon both as a field goal kicker and with his “dirty” kickoffs.
Let’s continue to enjoy these signs of life from the Cardiac Cats. Keep Pounding.
Source: https://www.catscratchreader.com/carolina-panthers-scores-results/56267/the-optimist-signs-of-life