The All-Star game is now behind us, and we’re in the lull before games kick back up and the second half begins. There’s still plenty of baseball left to play, but in the meantime we’ll take stock of the state of the 2025 season and weigh which team impressed the most during the first half of the season. A look at some of the league’s top teams:
Detroit Tigers (59-38)
Entering the All-Star break with MLB’s best record is a surefire way to get serious consideration for an accolade like this, but the Tigers are arguably even more impressive than their record lets on given just how much they’ve outperformed their preseason expectations.
Fangraphs projected the Tigers for a record of just 83-79, with a sub-50% chance to make the postseason. Detroit would have to win only 25 games over the season’s final ten weeks in order to beat that projection, thanks to strong performances from surprise All-Stars
Javier Baez,
Gleyber Torres, and
Zach McKinstry alongside the ever impressive work of stars like
Riley Greene and
Tarik Skubal.
Los Angeles Dodgers (58-39)
That the Dodgers have the best record in the National League is practically assumed in recent years, which speaks to the overwhelming dominance of the team Andrew Friedman and the rest of the front office have constructed.
Shohei Ohtani is back on the mound and putting together another likely MVP campaign,
Will Smith is having a career season behind the plate, and bottom-of-the-lineup players like
Andy Pages and
Hyeseong Kim are contributing. While dominance in Los Angeles is hardly a surprise, it’s nonetheless impressive that they’ve been able to maintain their high standard of play even in spite of the rising tide of competitive teams in the National League, extended slumps from both
Mookie Betts and
Freddie Freeman, and a patchwork rotation that at points in the first half had more Cy Young awards on the injured list than healthy members of its projected Opening Day rotation.
Chicago Cubs (57-39)
The Cubs’ front office entered 2025 feeling pressure after seven years without winning a playoff game and four without so much as a postseason appearance. That helped convince them to swing a trade for superstar
Kyle Tucker, who has anchored their lineup alongside breakout MVP candidate
Pete Crow-Armstrong. Tucker and Crow-Armstrong get the majority of the attention, but
Seiya Suzuki,
Michael Busch, and even veteran backstop
Carson Kelly have put together strong seasons in their own rights. A pitching staff that lost both of its top starters early has been carried by a strong showing from offseason addition
Matthew Boyd. It’s been enough to put them in the driver’s seat of the NL Central, and while that may have been expected entering the season, Chicago has made a statement by entering the second half in position to nab a bye through the Wild Card round.
Houston Astros (56-40)
After getting knocked out of the first round of the playoffs last year and the aforementioned Tucker trade, the Astros were a trendy pick to finally lose their grip on the AL West this year. They’ve answered the doubters impressively, plugging along despite getting virtually no production from
Yordan Alvarez—or any other left-handed hitter, for that matter.
Isaac Paredes has looked right at home in Daikin Park, and
Cam Smith has taken to the majors quite well despite being getting just a handful of games at the Double-A level ahead of his big league debut. The real story of the season for the Astros has been in the rotation, however, as
Hunter Brown has stepped up to make himself a true ace and legitimate Cy Young contender in a season where Houston would’ve otherwise had little certainty outside of pending free agent
Framber Valdez.
Toronto Blue Jays (55-41)
The narrative surrounding the Blue Jays was such a bleak one entering this season that it’s impossible to ignore how quickly they’ve managed to turn things around. After missing out on the big fish in free agency for the second consecutive year, it seemed entering the season that the questions facing Toronto this summer would be about the future of Ross Atkins as GM and whether or not they’d need to trade
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. before the deadline. A resurgent season from
George Springer, a career year for
Alejandro Kirk, and the breakout of
Addison Barger have come together to help push this club to the top of a competitive AL East, however, and with both Guerrero and Kirk locked up long term the Jays should be looking towards brighter days in the future, as well.
Other Options
While those five teams have put together some of the most impressive first halves of the season, they’re far from the only contenders. The Phillies and Mets are locked in a tight battle for control of the NL East, and the starting pitching in Queens has been a pleasant surprise given the contributions of pieces like
Griffin Canning (before his season-ending Achilles tear) and
Clay Holmes. The Giants and Cardinals both entered this season viewed as potential deadline sellers but have put together strong enough campaigns to remain within the thick of the playoff race.
The Brewers appeared to be a question mark after losing
Willy Adames and
Devin Williams this offseason, but they’re just one game back of the Cubs in the NL Central and might get even better down the stretch now that
Brandon Woodruff and
Jacob Misiorowski are contributing. The Mariners have been able to hang in the playoff picture despite lengthy absences for both
George Kirby and
Logan Gilbert, while the Yankees have overcome significant rotation injuries. The Rays entered the season without even having a proper ballpark and look as strong as ever even after selling off key pieces like Paredes and
Tyler Glasnow in recent years.
With so many strong performances in the first half, which team was the most impressive? Have your say in the poll below:
Take Our Poll
